From Algorithmic Error to Legal Deception: Redefining Responsibility in the Employment of Artificial Intelligence (A Case Study of the Atrocity at Shajareh Tayyebeh School in Minab)
Identification
- Clé publique
- radar:r-ef3f5abecf291afe59064e226d0f31a1
- Auteurs
- latifzadeh, Mahdieh
- Année déclarée
- 2026
- Langue déclarée
- fa
- Type source
- Preprint
- Première détection
- 2026-11-13T08:38:31.371321+00:00
- Dernière observation des métadonnées
- 2026-11-13T08:38:31.371321+00:00
- Dernière vérification HTTP
- Non effectuée
Institutions déclarées par la source
Assistant professor of private law, Department (The Research Group) of Islamic Jurisprudence and Law, Institute for Islamic Studies in Humanities, Ferdowsi University of Mashhad, Mashhad, Iran
Résumé documentaire — langue originale
Abstract Purpose: This research aims to examine the effects of deploying intelligent systems in high-risk domains (particularly in military operations) on the conventional mechanism for attributing legal responsibility. Its central question is to delineate the conceptual boundaries between “algorithmic error” as a technical defect devoid of criminal character, and “legal deception” as conduct attributable to a human agent. The case study of this research is the attack on Shajareh Tayyebeh School in Minab, Iran, which occurred during the war imposed on Iran by the United States and Israel on 28 February 2026 and resulted in the martyrdom and massacre of 168 children (referred to as shahid in Iran). This atrocity has been selected as the most concrete context for testing this theoretical distinction. Methodology: The research method is descriptive-analytical. Data collection is based on library resources, international documents (such as reports from human rights bodies like Amnesty International, the Office of the UN High Commissioner for Human Rights (OHCHR) , and Human Rights Watch), and an in-depth case analysis of the Minab atrocity. The method of analysis involves reconstructing the causal chain and examining the convergence of documented evidence (field, weaponry, and legal). The theoretical framework of the article is “explaining how algorithmic error transforms into legal deception,” under which the conditions that turn a technical malfunction into a tool for concealing human responsibility are elucidated. Findings: The research findings can be presented at two levels: macro (theoretical) and micro (case-specific). 1- Theoretical Findings: According to the theoretical findings of the research, artificial intelligence systems, despite their inherent lack of volition, intent, and legal personality, can assume a function beyond that of a neutral tool in specific operational settings. Under conditions where there is deficiency or bias in training data, weakness in verification protocols, a reduced level of effective human oversight, and imprudent reliance on technical outputs, AI becomes a factor that lends an appearance of legitimacy, conceals the true origin of decisions, and ultimately deepens the ambiguity in the process of attributing responsibility. From this perspective, AI lacks the agency to be a perpetrator; it is not an actor but a tool—an aggravating and accelerating factor for pre-existing structural deficiencies and a complicating variable in the causal relationship. 2- Case-Specific Findings (the Minab Atrocity): The analysis of this catastrophe as an objective instance confirms and complements the theoretical findings. Examination of the documents shows that in the targeting cycle leading to this attack, intelligent data processing systems such as “Project Maven” were used. These systems were employed to accelerate and prioritize the analysis of vast amounts of imagery data. However, their operation within a flawed organizational framework not only failed to correct existing errors, but turned into an accelerator for fundamental flaws. Accordingly, direct responsibility for this attack is attributed, based on a cohesive body of evidence, to the decision-makers and the United States Department of War. This evidence includes the definitive identification of the Tomahawk missile as the weapon used (which at that time was exclusively in the possession of U.S. forces), the use of outdated and inaccurate target databases belonging to the U.S. Defense Intelligence Agency (despite satellite images and maps clearly indicating the civilian use and visual features of the school for at least a decade prior), the occurrence of multiple strikes (including targeting the prayer hall where students had taken shelter after the initial strike and attacking rescue workers), and the organizational disbandment of specialized civilian casualty mitigation teams at the Pentagon, which led to a dangerous policy vacuum. In this case, the combination of the decision-makers’ knowledge of the outdated and unreliable nature of the underlying data, the deliberate weakening of human oversight and verification mechanisms, and the operational reliance on the outputs of a system generated from that same erroneous data caused a predictable intelligence “error” to turn into “legal deception.” This process manifestly violated the fundamental principles of International Humanitarian Law (including the principle of distinction between military and civilian objectives, the principle of proportionality in attack, and the principle of precaution in execution). Conclusion: The conclusion of the present research is that the legal solution to the challenges of accountability in the age of artificial intelligence lies not in seeking agency for the machine, but in redefining, clarifying, and strengthening the chain of human responsibility across all stages of design, development, regulation, deployment, and utilization of intelligent systems. In this regard, the demarcating line between mere algorithmic error and punishable legal deception is drawn in the areas of awareness (knowledge of limitations), volition (act or deliberate omission), data quality, and human oversight. Thus, whenever human actors, aware of the foreseeable deficiencies of a system, exploit it, weaken oversight mechanisms, or use technical complexity as a shield to justify catastrophic outcomes, legal analysis must go beyond the level of technical malfunction and assign responsibility directly to them. The atrocity at the Shajareh Tayyebeh School in Minab, as a case study, demonstrates how advanced technology, in a context of weak institutions, absent oversight frameworks, and imprudent practices, can not only fail to prevent harm, but become a factor in exacerbating harm and concealing responsibility. This event vividly reminds us that the question of responsibility in such cases, beyond abstract technological discussions, is directly tied to the fundamental right to life, the protection of civilians, and the integrity of the international legal system. Keywords: Attribution of Responsibility, The United States of America (USA), Project Maven, Black-Box Decision-Making, Misleading Output, Human Oversight Dedicated to the memory of the innocent children martyred in Minab: Makan Nasiri and Amir Ali Jedavi (whose remains were never recovered), Mikaeil Mirdoraghi, Mohammad Mehdi Jangichi (the only child of his family after 25 years), and the other martyred children of Minab. This manuscript is a preprint, meaning it is an author’s version shared prior to formal peer review and publication. The content is subject to change.
Identifiants
- DOI
- 10.5281/zenodo.20679586
- OAI
- oai:zenodo.org:20679586
Repères documentaires
- Famille documentaire
- unknown
- Types déclarés par les sources
- Preprint
- Éditeurs
- Zenodo
Les mentions d’entités ne constituent pas une preuve de reconnaissance juridique. La juridiction étudiée est distincte du pays d’affiliation des auteurs.
Sources
DataCite · Document 1
Citer cette référence
latifzadeh, Mahdieh. From Algorithmic Error to Legal Deception: Redefining Responsibility in the Employment of Artificial Intelligence (A Case Study of the Atrocity at Shajareh Tayyebeh School in Minab). 2026. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.20679586
JSON · CSL-JSON · BibTeX · RIS · CSV · JSON-LD ·
APA, Chicago, ISO 690 : formats bibliographiques fondés sur les champs disponibles. OSCOLA / Bluebook : données structurées uniquement ; aucune conformité juridique complète n’est revendiquée sans vérification des éléments nécessaires.
- APA
- latifzadeh, Mahdieh. (2026). From Algorithmic Error to Legal Deception: Redefining Responsibility in the Employment of Artificial Intelligence (A Case Study of the Atrocity at Shajareh Tayyebeh School in Minab). https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.20679586
- Chicago
- latifzadeh, Mahdieh. From Algorithmic Error to Legal Deception: Redefining Responsibility in the Employment of Artificial Intelligence (A Case Study of the Atrocity at Shajareh Tayyebeh School in Minab). 2026. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.20679586
- ISO 690
- latifzadeh, Mahdieh. From Algorithmic Error to Legal Deception: Redefining Responsibility in the Employment of Artificial Intelligence (A Case Study of the Atrocity at Shajareh Tayyebeh School in Minab). 2026. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.20679586
Warning: Undefined array key "last_link_verified" in /home/clients/e27d81e12f04d2bfd747aa264540ac56/sites/_UDTR_APP/legal_library_reference.php on line 31
UDTR — Bibliothèque juridique mondiale des droits de la Nature. From Algorithmic Error to Legal Deception: Redefining Responsibility in the Employment of Artificial Intelligence (A Case Study of the Atrocity at Shajareh Tayyebeh School in Minab). Notice documentaire: https://www.declarationuniverselledesdroitsdelarbre.org/global-rights-of-nature-radar/reference/r-ef3f5abecf291afe59064e226d0f31a1/ · Dernière vérification HTTP : non effectuée
Données de cette version figée
Dossiers et relations documentaires
Rôles des sources
Source bibliographique / publication d’origine · https://zenodo.org/doi/10.5281/zenodo.20679586
Un lien vers une autorité ne prouve pas à lui seul une affirmation juridique. Les résumés et les textes intégraux restent soumis aux conditions de leur source.
Statut documentaire
Pertinence à examiner
Bibliothèque
Cette identité n’est pas encore intégrée à la Bibliothèque juridique.