Radar mondial UDTR

UDTR — Radar mondial des droits de la Nature

Registre documentaire des références détectées à travers les infrastructures académiques, juridiques et institutionnelles surveillées par UDTR.

Une infrastructure documentaire mondiale conçue pour atteindre la couverture la plus large, vérifiable et scientifiquement défendable des droits de la Nature.

← Retour au Radar

aplicación de las asociaciones público-privadas en proyectos de infraestructura social en el departamento de cundinamarca (2021 – 2022)

Identification

Clé publique
radar:r-cc0ca2f138518e728201670bda612875
Auteurs
vargas leyton, luis carlos · lugo labrador, laura patricia
Année déclarée
—
Langue déclarée
Undetermined
Type source
UNKNOWN
Première détection
2026-11-13T09:02:49.089087+00:00
Dernière observation des métadonnées
2026-11-13T09:02:49.089087+00:00
Dernière vérification HTTP
Non effectuée

Résumé documentaire — langue originale

Application of Public-Private Partnerships in social infrastructure projects in the department of Cundinamarca (2021 - 2022). In most countries, the provision of infrastructure services is the responsibility of the public sector. Depending on the country's political and administrative structure, legislation may govern infrastructure sectors at different levels of local, provincial, and national government. And generally, some form of government authority is required to allow private participation in infrastructure development (Zúñiga, 2022). As legal provisions are necessary to process, promote and facilitate private participation, in many countries the procedures related to private sector participation are complex, numerous and dispersed in many different instruments, often unclear on many issues and do not have a fixed deadline for their completion. In particular, the legal regime of Public Private Associations (hereinafter APP) can be dispersed among many instruments that include the law of private contracts, company law, tax law, labor law, competition law, the right of consumer protection, insolvency law, infrastructure sector law, property law, foreign investment law, intellectual property, environmental, Public Procurement Law or Regulations, Acquisition or Appropriation Law and many other Laws, or as directed in this document from the bases of administrative law (Ibagón and Santofimio, 2018). According to Zúñiga (2022), after the 2008 financial crisis, there has been a growing interest in Public-Private Partnerships (PPPs) in both developed and developing countries. As governments face limited public resources and fiscal space, while recognizing the importance of investing in infrastructure to foster economic growth, they are increasingly turning to the private sector as an additional alternative source of financing to fill the financing gap. . Although recent attention has been focused on fiscal risk, governments now partner with the private sector for a variety of reasons, such as: • Use PPPs as a means to incorporate technology and innovation from the private sector in order to improve the delivery of public services through greater operational efficiency. • Stimulate the private sector to deliver projects on time and within the agreed budget. • Establish budget certainty by determining the present and future costs of infrastructure projects over time. It is important to highlight that these partnerships between the public and private sectors can offer win-win solutions, while contributing to the development of crucial infrastructures for the economic and social well-being of the countries involved. Indeed, using PPPs as a way to develop the capacities of the local private sector through joint ventures with large international companies generates subcontracting opportunities for local companies in areas such as civil works, electrical works, facilities management, security services, cleaning services, maintenance services. Public-Private Partnerships (PPPs) are a gradual path to increasingly involve the private sector, especially foreign companies, in cooperation with state-owned companies and the government. The purpose of this structuring is to guarantee the transfer of skills, thus allowing local contractors to improve their professional skills and, in the long term, have the opportunity to export their knowledge through tenders for various projects. In relation to the above, this research thesis to qualify for the master's degree seeks to reflect that the PPPs could contribute to the development of the region of the Department of Cundinamarca at different levels of government, as means for the municipalities to develop and take course to the millennium sustainability goals and respond to the innumerable needs of its citizens. Regarding the approach to the problem, in Colombia for years the National Planning Department - DNP has been supporting Private Participation in Infrastructure - PA. PP , as an administrative measure for the provision of public goods and their related services. In figures as shown in figure 1, in the last twenty-five years investment has exceeded nine hundred billion pesos and this has allowed investment in public infrastructure such as improvements to tertiary roads, construction of hospitals, schools, treatment plants, satisfying the basic needs of citizens. As indicated by the National Planning Department- DNP (2021); The country ranks 2nd for its capacity to develop PPPs according to the 2019 Infrascope (Chile ranks 1st), surpassing the average of the countries in the region (LAC) in all measurement categories. This, partly thanks to the issuance of Law 1508 of 2012 (p.6). This has projected the development of territorial entities, making efficient and sophisticated mechanisms affordable to access public infrastructure and the services that this infrastructure can provide, in fact, to date according to the National Planning Department- DNP (2021); "Colombia ranks 2nd in the world for the development of projects under the PPP scheme, according to the World Bank ranking in 2019, after a tie for first place between the United Kingdom and Australia" (p.6). This is because historically, public-private partnerships have been justified by the scarcity of resources from the administration to finance large public works for the low-income population. Given this, the union between private and public entities provides the possibility of carrying out these projects more efficiently, since the private sector has more agile means to do so. According to the Single Registry of Public-Private Associations (RUA.P.P) of 2021, the Capital District of Bogotá leads with 61 projects, representing 21.18% of the total current projects (288). In second place are the departments of Antioquia with 36 initiatives (12.50%), Bolívar with 29 (10.07%), Santander with 26 (9.03%) and Cundinamarca with 22 (7.64%) ( page 6). According to figure 2, in 2021, the department of Cundinamarca only had 1 PPP project in progress in the feasibility stage, while 4 projects were in the pre-feasibility phase. This finding should be considered when reviewing the figures of the diagnosis of the department according to strategic axes, for the last mandate published by the Government of Cundinamarca (2019) being the last report published, this in the understanding that the true situation of access roads, climatic changes that are not expected, the weak budget structure for the acquisition of equipment with technology and other conditions that affect the development in part of any infrastructure project. This indicates that in the case of the Department of Cundinamarca, Public-Private Partnerships (PPPs) could stimulate the economy by making the region more competitive by improving its facilitating infrastructure, while boosting industries related to the development of such infrastructure, such as construction, equipment, and support services. In addition, these PPPs could supplement the limited capacities of the public sector to meet the growing demand for infrastructure development. At the same time, they would allow long-term value to be realized through adequate risk transfer to the private sector throughout the entire project cycle, from design and construction to operations and maintenance. In this regard, according to the Territorial Development Bank (2022), public-private collaboration facilitates large-scale projects, such as infrastructures, since the private sector has more agile means to carry it out, in addition to limiting the risk derived from delay, since the same sector incurs an obligation of result. Another benefit exposed by the author is that of the value of money, which is achieved through an efficient allocation of risk. In addition, since the project is financed by the private sector, it does not depend on public debt to do so. Finally, this would also encourage new investment and minimize the costs of the State. Therefore, the following is presented as a research question: 3. Establish the contribution to the development of the Department of Cundinamarca of Public-Private Associations in light of the principle of proportionality in accordance with the method of the five justifications directed by the National Planning Department. As a hypothesis, it was identified that the participation of PPPs by the Department of Cundinamarca enhances the development of the region by generating tools to improve administrative performance, investment for infrastructure and that this impacts basic sanitation and community care. Due to the exposed context, the methodology of this thesis is oriented in the socio-critical paradigm, that is, in critical theory with the genesis of knowing and understanding practical reality, integrating knowledge of a transversal entity. This research model is par with historical hermeneutics. Hence, it is highlighted that this research prototype questions the neutrality of other science and therefore promotes individual reflection. Hence, it is affirmed that this socio-criticized paradigm has as its objective the vision of overcoming ideas of a limiting nature (Hernández and Torres, 2018). As Concepción (2019) points out, research planning leads to generating procedures for the collection, analysis and mixing of research in order to understand and comprehend the subject of the research, hence it is necessary to mix research processes, whether qualitative or quantitative, with the purpose of expanding the credibility of the findings. Theoretical foundations of Public-Private Associations and their incidence in the Department of Cundinamarca Public-private collaboration is defined as a long-term contractual relationship in which the State and the private sector establish agreements to develop public infrastructure and social services (Castillo and Bustos, 2021). In the field of administrative law, Public-Private Associations (PPP) are considered an important form of hybrid organization that, if properly applied in primary care, the design and management of state policies, can guarantee the implementation of innovative solutions to complex problems by combining different institutional mechanisms (Zúñiga, 2022). At a global level, as indicated by the Territorial Development Bank (2022), PPPs are a preferred approach to supply public infrastructure on a large scale, under the conditions of formation of a new type of relationship, State - private sector - society, for this reason new forms and new elements are emerging that transform PPP mechanisms. The basic characteristics of PPPs are the public, private and civil society participants in donor and recipient countries, who share resources, risks and responsibilities among the partners, depending on the degree of association based on commitment and in turn on the type of relationship; like the contractual So, the organization of the association based on the form and decision-making, alignment and consideration of the local context and regulations, must respond to the common objective of promoting progress in the countries of the developing world with the specific function of the association of generating sustainable effects in the form of a lasting impact for the regions, beyond the association itself (Alfaro and Hernández, 2019). Thus, many countries have enacted special legal and regulatory instruments and have amended their existing infrastructure sector laws. Legislation can also play an important role in facilitating the issuance of licenses and permits that may be required for project implementation (González, 2021). These include licenses to establish a company by the concessionaire, license for the exploration and extraction of mineral resources, work permits for foreigners, import permits, license for equipment and other supplies, construction permits, as well as allocation of radio frequency spectrum for telecommunications and television transmission. Regarding the special legal instruments, they can specify the types of PPP models allowed, the general conditions for these models, the guidelines on joint risk agreements, the provision of financial and other incentives, and can provide details on the identification, approval and acquisition of projects, including the negotiation of contracts and the conclusion of contracts, agreements and implementation arrangements in government administrative bodies (Castillo and Bustos, 2021). However, the legal instruments of many countries do not provide details on the association agreements and the administrative process, it should be noted that particularly in the case of Colombia, the laws that relate to the PPP are Law 1508 of 2012, Decree 2767 of 2012, DNP Resolution 3656 of 2012, Law 1593 of 2012 and Decree 1793 of 2021 are one of those legal effects that can define the division of responsibilities between different levels of government. Next, figure 3 groups the national regulatory framework for PPPs In addition to the above, Judgment C-346 I quote; In accordance with the constitutional principles indicated and the jurisprudence of this Corporation, the Legislator is empowered to prohibit the execution of public-private association contracts in the last year of government of the territorial authorities. In short, the rule of law contained in the challenged rule does not ignore the autonomy of territorial entities, since it is a restriction that belongs to the sphere of legislative configuration, since its purpose is to guarantee orderly planning, so that governors and mayors execute their programs sufficiently in advance, in order to: (i) make them compatible with development plans, and (ii) prevent local governments from compromising future validity, so that those who succeed them can execute their own government programs. Consequently, the enforceability of the accused rule will be declared. (Constitutional Court, Judgment C-346, 2017, p.1) Urging that the territorial entities respond to the basic sanitation needs of their communities in an orderly and regulated manner by the territorial management described in development plans for the current term, without compromising the rubles of future administrations. On the other hand, Judgment C-207/19 pointed out; Given the characteristics of PPP and road infrastructure works concession contracts, in which most of the capital at risk belongs to bona fide third parties and, in particular, to savings collected from the public, the restitutions that may arise in cases in which the absolute nullity of one of these contracts is declared shall be governed by the general rule of good faith protection, and therefore, must be directed primarily to satisfy the payment of the debts that the project has acquired with bona fide third parties. (Constitutional Court, Judgment C-207, 2019, p.1). Since PPPs can be defined in general terms as a contractual agreement between the government and a private company aimed at financing, designing, implementing and operating infrastructure facilities and services that were traditionally provided by the public sector. It incorporates the optimal allocation of risks between the parties, minimizing costs while meeting the development objectives of the project. Therefore, the project must be structured in such a way that the private sector obtains a reasonable rate of return on its investment. While PPPs offer monetary and non-monetary advantages for the public sector, they address limited funding resources for local infrastructure or public sector development projects, allowing the allocation of public funds for other local priorities. It is a mechanism to distribute the risks of the project to both the public and private sectors, because it is oriented so that both sectors obtain greater efficiency and project implementation processes in the provision of services to the public. Most importantly, APP emphasizes value for money, focusing on cost reduction, better risk allocation, faster implementation, improved services, and potential additional revenue generation. Therefore, when there are signs of corruption or mismanagement of resources according to jurisprudence, for example, for Sentence C-207/19, entities such as the comptroller's office must intervene in the APP, terminate it or pause it for the general good. In this scenario for the line of Conpes 3961 on contractual risk policy guidelines of the state for passenger rail system projects co-financed by the nation. The different Conpes, such as Conpes 4000, Conpes 4028, Conpes 4047 and Conpes 4060, define guidelines for the State's contractual risk policy for airport projects, infrastructure in waterways and navigable channels, railway cargo systems and transportation projects. sustainable transport infrastructure with private participation in the country (Ministry of Finance and Public Credit, 2022). Depending on various reasons, the government may choose to enact a Public-Private Partnership (PPP) law or a concessions law. This may be for the purpose of prioritizing a PPP project development, contracting, and review process that takes precedence over existing sectoral laws, or to establish a clear institutional framework for PPP development, contracting, and implementation. PPP laws can also be used to close gaps in a host country's laws that may necessitate successful infrastructure PPP projects, such as allowing the granting of rights of interest to lenders and requiring open and fair procurement processes. These modifications may be embodied in a sectoral law, or in the case of procurement, a procurement or competition law, or they may be included in a general concession or PPP law. This site includes links to guidance on drafting concession PPP laws and examples of enacted PPP laws. While guidance and examples can be helpful, each PPP grant law needs careful wording to be consistent with the existing laws of the host country. Legal drafters must strike a balance between establishing ground rules that encourage transparency and imposing blanket restrictions that may prevent bidding teams from achieving value for money or sensible solutions when bidding on PPP projects. The PPP Law in Colombia (Law 1508 of 2012) in; Article 1. Definition. Public Private Associations are an instrument for linking private capital, which are embodied in a contract between a state entity and a natural or legal person under private law, for the provision of public goods and their related services, which involves the retention and risk transfer between the parties and payment mechanisms, related to the availability and service level of the infrastructure and/or service (Law 1508 of 2012, art.1). The purpose of the advice provided is to contribute to the establishment of a legal framework that promotes private investment in public infrastructure. It seeks to strike a balance between facilitating and stimulating private sector participation in infrastructure projects, while addressing various public interest concerns of the host country. From 2012 to date, the legislative language contained in its model provisions on privately financed infrastructure projects has been suggested. Being of primary interest because the administrative mechanism for the implementation of the PPP project depends on the government system and the general administrative structure, and the legal regime related to PPPs. As these elements vary from one country to another, the administrative mechanism also varies from one country to another (Rodríguez, 2020). Therefore, depending on a country's system, the implementation of PPP projects may require the participation of various authorities at various levels of government, where the authority to award PPP contracts and approve contractual agreements is generally centralized in a separate authority (Beltrán, 2017). From which it can be inferred that, generally, the sectoral agencies at the national and departmental levels as a decentralized structure initiate and implement the majority of the PPP projects. It is worth making a distinction that, in many countries such as Colombia, for example, local governments can also undertake PPP projects (Vergara, 2020). And sometimes this comes to define from the administrative skills of the collaborator the scope of benefits for citizens that this PPP could generate or the administrative powers that public law attributes to the officials at the head of the corporations (Buesaquillo and López, 2019 ). Understanding that PPPs are based on two fundamental principles; both parties invest in the project. In a financial sense labor, materials budget and in a sense related to experience, knowledge and networks. Where they consequently contribute to a social and often also a commercial purpose and because legal instruments or government norms and guidelines define how sectoral agencies and local governments can initiate, develop, submit to national, provincial or municipal government approval, contract, negotiate and make deals with the private sector, and finally implement a project. Considering that the legal instruments of many countries do not provide details on the association agreements and the administrative process (Martínez, 2020). This generates that the administrative instrument of the PPPs is delineated with as many definitions as contract modalities are signed, where the authority and responsibilities of the government entities and the PPP rapporteurs are defined from the legal instruments, causing in turn that the procedures respond to various tasks and the administrative approval of the competent authorities in the different stages of the project implementation process are necessary to execute a successful PPP program. Ideally here, simplified administrative procedures would reduce uncertainties at different stages of project development and approval and help reduce the transaction cost of a PPP project. But in reality, the administrative process of the associations responds to project identification particularities such as internal preparatory arrangements, conceptual structure of the project, due institutionality through the legal and regulatory framework, government policy, participation of other departments, internal capacity, strategies of project implementation, establishment of project committees, government approval such as by a special body established for PPPs, appointment of a transaction advisor if necessary, terms of reference and appointment until government approval (Nader, 2021 ). Social infrastructure projects are booming in Latin America, certain innovative tools such as public-private associations or alliances are becoming more relevant as an increasingly attractive option to materialize this type of project, by guaranteeing the efficiency and quality of hospitals, roads and educational centers, among others. Historically, public-private partnerships are justified by the scarcity of resources from the administration to finance large public works for the low-income population. Given this, the union between private and public entities would provide the possibility of carrying out these projects more efficiently, since the private sector has more agile means to do so. In this context, unlike privatization, the public partner maintains full control of the project, while the private sector is limited to providing the necessary capital (Solarte, 2015). In Colombia, there is a trend towards sustainable development with regard to social infrastructure, prioritizing initiatives that meet present needs without compromising the ability of future generations to meet their own needs. Here it is essential to note that administrative law guidelines encompass the set of laws, procedures, and legal institutions affecting government entities as they implement legislation and administer public programs, which imply important political and social values, including democracy, equity, and efficiency. That they have been fundamental in designing rules that better promote these values, and in part because of empirical efforts to explain how the law influences the behavior of government agencies (López, et al., 2019). Since government entities often possess considerable political discretion, they are staffed by unelected officials, a key issue in administrative law for understanding how agencies are, or can be, democratically accountable. Here administrative law also places special emphasis on empirical understanding of the impact of courts on agencies, for judicial review has been considered a method of holding administrators accountable for democratic legislative decisions. And as Ibagón and Santofimio (2018) indicate, administrative law is based on the methods and findings of the social sciences to understand how the law can affect governance and improve the results of public institutions, because, in some countries, they have established special PPP units in governments under the provisions of such special legal instruments, where these PPP units facilitate the development and implementation of PPP projects According to Nader (2021), the growing and complex demands in a constantly changing world have led governments to delegate traditionally public functions to the private sector. States have gone from being producers of goods and services to playing a more regulatory and supervisory role in the economy and the market. Public-Private Associations (PPP) propose cooperation between public and private entities to offer public utility services, with the participation of both parties and with economic or social advantages for both. What distinguishes PPPs from state privatization is that, in the first case, the final responsibility for providing the service falls on the public entity, while, in privatization, the private sector is in charge of providing the service. However, in this last situation, the public entity cannot ignore the quality of the services, since the company selected to carry out the service was chosen through a contest. Consequently, States with a visionary economic and social vision, based on factual studies and considering world evolution, give great importance to PPPs. As Colombia is a Social State of Law, with abundant territorial biodiversity and exceptional human talent, the possibilities of becoming a highly developed country in various sectors increase. And this is how PPPs emerge as a mechanism so that this "unreachable" project can be carried out in a given territory, either due to ignorance of regulations or simply due to lack of human and economic resources, the purpose of the Program of Support for Private Participation in Infrastructure - PA.PP, in addition to accompanying projects of great importance, is to give value and prominence to the private sector which, with its economic and human resources through a proposal, logically supported by the State, provide a productive service or optimal social benefit whose benefit is totally and reasonably aimed at covering certain needs of the Colombian people. In order to achieve the competitiveness required by the country in the context of free trade agreements and its global positioning, the active participation of the private sector in the supply of public goods is essential, especially in areas such as infrastructure and related activities. However, despite the aforementioned benefits, there are certain drawbacks in the application of associations, such as the difficulty of associations, the potential dangers of establishing a good cost-effectiveness relationship in the financial package, for this reason it is necessary to consider associations, as a form of State capacity to invest in sectors of essential importance for the development of the country. In addition, collaboration contracts attract private investment for actors in which public resources would be insufficient (Maldonado, 2018). When analyzing the regional development opportunities that could arise through the participation of Public-Private Associations (PPPs) in the Government of Cundinamarca, it is relevant to take into account the current trends in administrative law, which tend to address technical and specialized areas that are considered complex or cumbersome from the point of view of legislative procedures, making it difficult for the legislature to continue their treatment. Regarding the historical evolution of PPPs in social infrastructure projects in the department of Cundinamarca, it is essential to highlight that in any territory there is a close relationship between infrastructure and development. Ultimately, the ability to attract investment, promote entrepreneurship, generate employment and even improve the quality of life of the population are closely linked to the elements that make up the socio-spatial structure of a place or region. The infrastructure for social development is the set of basic elements that provide the minimum material conditions necessary for any public or private company, of particular or shared interest. The main elements that make up the infrastructure of a place are; power generation, the transportation system, telecommunications and other services considered fundamental, such as sanitation, the presence of educational and health institutions, among others. In this context, infrastructure is also related to logistical aspects that serve the development of the country, of which transportation, communications, and energy sources are the primary factors. After all, if a country does not have an energy supply that guarantees the absence of blackouts, if it does not have an articulated transport network that allows the fast and cheap flow of production and trade, and also if there is no integrated communications system, investments decrease and it is not possible to think about economic and social development. As a result, production falls, consumption falls, job creation falls, and the economy weakens. In the department of Cundinamarca, these elements are considered true bottlenecks for growth like the region, especially transportation and the generation of basic sanitation. In the first sector, the main challenge is to reduce the preponderance of the road modal without harming the quality of the roads, in addition to improving air services. Although there are government efforts to develop them, there is still no short-term solution to these problems, but it is necessary to point out that improving the infrastructure conditions of the country and the regions is to improve the socioeconomic conditions of the entire population and, thus, generate more investment and also more jobs. Therefore, it is necessary to reduce the costs of industry, livestock, agriculture and commerce to reduce the price of products, generate more profits for investors and promote income distribution measures, another important challenge to overcome in Colombia and in several countries around the world. In figures according to the DNP (2022) "$208 billion are necessary, by 2035, for the Intermodal Transport Master Plan - PMTI" (p.16), $182 billion is required in road network intervention, build at least 31 airports, in addition $4.3 billion is required to guarantee access to affordable energy for all. On the other hand, according to the DNP (2022), it is necessary to generate an investment of $29.2 billion for aqueduct and $14.2 billion for basic sanitation. In the case of the department of Cundinamarca, there are four macro areas that influence the movement of people and merchandise and also the productive process as regions, which results in economic growth. Sanitation: here we can include the collection of garbage, the supply of treated water, the collection and treatment of domestic and industrial wastewater, as well as the cleaning of public roads. These services are essential for disease prevention and increasing the quality of life and well-being of the population. On the other hand, transport: investment in urban mobility and in the construction of roads, airports, and improving railways is essential for economic development, since it affects the movement of people and goods. In terms of energy, this is one of the main infrastructure services, both in its generation and distribution, since energy is important for the supply of homes, companies and industries, as well as rustic farms and vehicles. The last area to intervene is telecommunications: it is essential for the exchange of information between people and companies from different places, that is, for conducting business. This can be done via cell phone, landline, internet, radio and other means. Faced with these, the actions underway in terms of strengthening the infrastructure of the department are according to the Government of Cundinamarca (2022); The bidding for the Rionegro trunk line, which will have an investment of $90,000 million; and the Sibaté-Fusagasugá-Pasca, San Francisco-Supatá and Briceño-Zipaquirá highways, with resources totaling more than $400,000 million, the construction of the Los Chorros viaduct on the Chuguacal-Cambao highway, a project of strategic importance to which they will inject $75,000 million. Likewise, he socialized the works of the Tabio-Siberia road, which is already in bidding; the third lane of the Cota – Chía road; and the dual carriageway of the Cota variant, which already has the studies and designs, so far in 2022 $1.2 trillion in road and social infrastructure projects have been executed. (p.1). In this regard, the National Planning Department and the Fiscal Decentralization and Strengthening Directorate (2022), evaluate the dimension of financial management by budget category for the departments, the analysis of financial ratios as a financial performance analysis tool is generally applied to foundations of business organizations, while public companies, especially local ones, are still very limited, so hypothetically there is no consistent regulation. It is of the utmost importance that the regional financial management structure be transparent, honest, democratic, efficient and accountable. To achieve this, it is essential to carry out a detailed analysis of the financial ratios of both the regional income budget and the expenditure budget. The results obtained through this analysis of financial ratios serve as a reference to evaluate the level of independence, efficiency, utility, harmony, growth and development in financial management. This approach is crucial to assess the responsibility of organizations and managers in the provision of public services, and goes beyond simply demonstrating that public money has been spent, but instead focuses on demonstrating that spending has been efficient and effective. As shown in Figure 4, the National Planning Department and the Fiscal Decentralization and Strengthening Directorate (2022) rank the department of Cundinamarca as one of the three solvent departments in the country. As shown in figure 6, Cundinamarca surpasses regions such as Valle del Cauca and Antioquia in the fiscal performance index in 2021, according to the report of the National Infrastructure Agency (ANI) (2019), this is due to important concession actions and other types of projects such as PPPs executed by the government. It is relevant to highlight that during the year 2018, the Government of Cundinamarca and the Regional Ferrea Company established an inter-administrative association agreement with the main objective of joining efforts for the preparation, analysis, review and diagnosis of a concession contract that includes technical aspects , administrative, social, property, environmental, accounting, legal, financial and risk. The purpose of said contract was to acquire rolling stock and be in charge of the operation and maintenance of the western Regiotram system, with the deadline set for December 31, 2018. It is important to note that Regiotram was one of the first private companies accepted by the ANI and the Government of Cundinamarca to lead this project, and the company Férrea Regional was in charge of the entire contracting process. Another important work is that of the Bogotá - Villavicencio road Section 1: Bogotá - El Tablón, from the year 2015. As well as the dual carriageway improvement Villeta - Guaduas by public initiative in structuring. And the contracting of the dual carriageway Zipaquirá - Barbosa Santander, who manage the public sector by the ANI. In relation to item number 17 of the Concession contract No. 0377 of 2002 of the Bogotá-Tunja-Sogamoso (BTS) Highway, the construction of the bypass of the municipality of Gachancipá, located in Cundinamarca, was carried out. According to the General Royalty System (SGR) (2022), Cundinamarca has available balances for the approval of projects in the Regional Compensation Fund, the Regional Development Fund and the Assignment for Peace, with a total amount of 1,567,000,000 million pesos. This amount includes the budget for the 2019-2020 period established by Law 1942 of December 27, 2018, as well as remaining balances from previous periods. It is important to note that the value may vary due to the approval of new projects or adjustments registered in the Unified System of Public Investment and Finance (SUIFP), as well as the disapproval of projects or the release of balances. Regarding the execution of projects, 72% of the projects have been completed so far, 22% are in the process of execution and the remaining 5% have not yet been contracted with said budget. Regarding the type of contraction, as shown in Figure 6, 81% is done by bidding and 9% by public bidding, the co-financing comes from the General System of Participations (SGP), unrestricted current income (ICLD), other income ceded to health, internal and external credit, specific destination current income, national co-financing, other capital resources and departmental co-financing. Of these, projects such as Cundinamarca Agrotec, water park, future center savannah, western and Soacha ring equipment, development promotion, design of the tourist plan for the province of Sumapaz, Bogotá eco-park, community development region library, toy library and traveling cinema have been projected as an investment plan. In the period from 2014 to 2022, the PPPs in Cundinamarca have had a continuous growth as shown in figure 8, in the period described the Department, started with 0 participations and has evolved continuously until 2018, with a lapse of decrease in the year 2019 going from 94 PPPs to 24 PPPs, since that period it has continued making participations in the PPP for an average of 22 contractions per year. Regarding the evolution of Cundinamarca PPPs between 2014 and 2022 compared to regions, Figure 8 shows that the department has remained between third and fifth place in the ranking of national PPPs, surpassing regions such as Barranquilla, Cúcuta, Ibagué, Antioquia, Tolima, Quindío and Valle Del Cauca, for the period described and has always been preceded by Bogotá Region, which has historically been the territory with the most contracted PPPs. The principle of proportionality and the method of the five justifications directed by the National Planning Department The ability to reason using proportional relationships results from a complex process that takes time to assimilate, many and varied concrete experiences are needed to understand the nature of a proportional relationship, and it takes even longer to acquire the ability to make abstract applications. It is true that no field of law, no jurisdiction escapes the application of the principle of proportionality, for Ferreres (2020) it is a weighting mechanism between legal principles, of equivalent rank, simultaneously applicable, but contradictory. And that naturally affirms itself as a guarantor of individual liberties and that of other legitimate purposes, such as the safeguarding of the general interest and, in particular, the protection of public order or the effectiveness of public action. 2.1 Principle of proportionality As Hernández (2019) turns out, the principle of proportionality is a concept in law, the term has several meanings according to the legislation and can be defined in a general way as a principle of adaptation of the means to an end. Applying the principle of proportionality means checking the balance between the objective pursued and the decision made, but it is also using the means provided to solve a problem, that is, for example, making the decision that least violates a freedom to achieve the objective pursued. The principle of proportionality is thus reminiscent of compliance, fully supported by the idea of effectiveness, which is a right of compliance and which, anchored in it, must limit its effectiveness. It is therefore a kind of price that these techniques pay, with regret, to the Rule of Law and in particular to the freedoms of human beings (Hernández, 2019). Initially of a mathematical nature, the notion of proportionality appeared in the field of law from a penal angle. As a component of the hierarchy of norms, proportionality constitutes a general principle of law whose compliance the judge ensures in the context of the control of legality and constitutionality. This implies, in particular, in the field of competition law, that the fines must not be disproportionate in relation to the objectives pursued, that is, in relation to compliance with this law, and that the amount of the fine imposed on a company for a competition infringement must be proportionate to the infringement, evaluated as a whole, taking into account, in particular, its seriousness (Carbonell, 2010). As an intellectual instrument, the principle of proportionality allows the national competition authorities and the Constitutional Court to arrive at the adoption of precautionary measures or adequate sanctions, which the judge will control and, where appropriate, will sanction preferably within the framework of its full competence, that is, of its power to reform. While, in the first case, it is simply up to the judge to determine whether or not a decision violates said principle, which constitutes an analytical sieve that is sometimes too coarse, the job of the judge leads him, in the second case, to verify whether the measure that presented to him is the most adequate possible, which means that he ensures its exact proportionality and, where appropriate, substitutes his own appreciation for that of the author of the decision with the desired delicacy (Carbonell, 2010). The first manifestations of the principle of proportionality, albeit indirectly, took place in Ancient Greece, where the idea prevailed that the law would serve as a means for individuals to live in community (Carbonell, 2010). Every man feels that what is disproportionate is unfair. Even in the aesthetics of ancient Greece, the main requirement of proportion arises. Everywhere, those who are rewarded too little or punished too much, feel in their flesh the obvious injustice that resides in the disproportion. This may have been the main reason why Aristotle considered fairness to be the conforming link between law and justice. In fact, in an excerpt from his Nicomachean Ethics, Plato's main disciple already embodied the concept of proportionality linked to his distributive justice: Virtue is, then, a disposition of character related to choice and constituted by a medium, that is, the medium relative to us, which is determined by a rational principle proper to the man endowed with wisdom. And it is a compromise between two vices, one due to excess and the other due to lack; given that; while vices go too far or do not reach what is convincing in terms of actions and passions, virtue finds and chooses the middle ground (Carbonell, 2010). Specifically dealing with the principle of proportionality, without a doubt, much is owed to the German Constitutional Court - Bundesverfassungsgericht - for its evolution and consecration in Constitutional Law. Justifying the origin of the principle of proportionality, it is said that this would not be more than the principle of reasonableness of North American law. Which is not true, as a consequence of the principle of due legal process, it has had a recognized participation in the jurisprudence of the Supreme Court of the United States during the last two centuries. The extrajudicial clause of due process, which dates back to 1215 in England, over time was protected by the strictly procedural nature, and by the substantial nature, from which the principle of reasonableness was born (Carbonell, 2010). The principle of proportionality, derived from the Rule of Law, directly linked to fundamental rights, occupying the role of governing norm of all state activity and serving as a form of control of the constitutionality of such measures, had a clear evolution in the German Constitutional Court, specifically after the Second World War, from the promulgation of the Basic Law of Germany (Constitution of Bonn), which took place in 1949 (Carbonell, 2010). The principle of proportionality plays a particularly important role in the field of Administrative Law, since, in a Rule of Law, the administration is limited to adopting only the measures strictly necessary to maintain or restore public order. On some occasions, the administration may take measures that imply certain restrictions to the recognized rights; however, these actions are justified by the existence of specific needs that explain their implementation by the authorities. This situation occurs particularly in areas such as freedom of expression, freedom of movement, and freedom of demonstration and assembly. The epistemological foundation of the principle of proportionality consists in responding equitably, when it comes to a fundamental right and the contested measure constitutes, in the exercise of that right, an interference that has a clear and accessible legal basis in domestic law. And that it is justified by a legitimate purpose, such interference constitutes an excessive violation of the fundamental right in relation to this legitimate purpose (Hernández, 2019). Hernández (2019) explains that the principle of proportionality is a complex implementation, particularly because the mode of reasoning that supports it is quite alien to the logic of French law. Indeed, the control of conventionality of the standard of national law implies not only determining if it satisfies in abstracto itself , the requirements of this text, but also if its application to the specific case does not create a disproportionate interference in the exercise of the right. protected. Judgment C-022/96 indicated; The concept of proportionality serves as a point of support for the balance between constitutional principles: when two principles collide, because the application of one implies the reduction of the field of application of another, it is up to the constitutional judge to determine if this reduction is proportionate, in light of the importance of the affected principle. The concept of proportionality comprises three partial concepts: the adequacy of the means chosen to achieve the end pursued, the need to use these means to achieve the end (that is, that there is no other means that can lead to the end and that sacrifices to a lesser extent the constitutional principles affected by the use of those means), and proportionality in the strict sense between the means and the end, that is, that the principle satisfied by the achievement of this end does not sacrifice constitutionally more important principles (Constitutional Court). al, Judgment C-022, 1996, p.1). The principle of proportionality implies a delicate balance between the intervention of public powers for the sake of the general interest and the protection of the rights and freedoms of citizens, which is similar to a metaphor for justice. In this way, it seeks to achieve a balance between each of the elements present in this equation (Hernández, 2019). Therefore, any measure that restricts rights and freedoms must be adequate, necessary and proportionate: adequate, in the sense that it must allow the legitimate objective pursued to be achieved. The principle of proportionality is not limited simply to the contentious function of the judge when arbitrating between contradictory principles; instead, it is applied more broadly to all public actions and is established as a general principle. According to Hernández (2019), even the legislator must respect this principle when enacting laws, and it is also applied horizontally in relations between citizens or individuals. When carrying out an investigative process, the principle of proportionality is used, which in its most basic form encompasses the common sense idea that when the government acts, the means it chooses must be adequate to achieve the ends it pursues. As Hernández (2019) highlighted, proportionality is widely recognized in comparative law and has been adopted as an essential component in numerous national and international legal systems in recent years. Furthermore, it has been the subject of considerable scholarly interest and, in some cases, has been the subject of criticism. However, much of the attention has focused on the use of proportionality in the realm of constitutional law, where it is applied as a technique to resolve claims related to the constitutional rights of citizens and regions. In Ruling C-022/96 reference was made to this issue: In the specific case of the principle of equality, the concept of proportionality means, therefore, that unequal treatment does not violate that principle only if it is shown to be (1) adequate to achieve a constitutionally valid purpose; (2) necessary, that is, there is no less onerous means, in terms of the sacrifice of other constitutional principles, to reach the end; and (3) proportionate, that is, that unequal treatment does not sacrifice values and principles (among which is the principle of equality) that have a greater weight than the principle that is sought to be satisfied by said treatment (Constitutional Court, Judgment C-022, 1996, p.3). In turn, this principle includes three fundamental sub-principles: adequacy, necessity and proportionality in the strict sense. When analyzing the constitutionality of a specific act using the principle of proportionality, it is necessary to submit it to an orderly analysis of these three sub-principles, as Hernández (2019) points out. It is important to highlight that the principle of proportionality not only pursues the objective of reasonableness to avoid arbitrary measures (negative effectiveness), but also guarantees the effectiveness of fundamental rights (positive effectiveness). All this implies that an act can be reasonable but not proportional, which means that it has not been subjected to the examination of the three sub-principles that make up the principle of proportionality. Ruling C-022/20 provided greater clarity on this matter; In this regard, the Court recalls that the principle of proportionality is a methodological tool that seeks to provide rationality, predictability, and legitimacy to the decision adopted by the judge, making use of a structure that is made up of three sub-principles: suitability, necessity, and proportionality in the strict sense. This trial seeks to analyze whether a measure under study is adequate to achieve the proposed purpose. Immediately afterwards, the necessity analysis must be carried out, by virtue of which it is appreciated, if the measure chosen by the Legislator is the least restrictive of other principles, considering its invalidity in the event that there is another with a lower impact and with a similar suitability for obtaining the purposes of the regulatory authority. Finally, the study of proportionality in the strict sense is specified in a consideration between the goods or principles in conflict, which includes consideration of their abstract weight, the intensity of the affectation - benefit, and finally, some considerations -in case of having the elements - on the certainty of the effects of such a relationship (Constitutional Court, Judgment C-022, 2020, p.2). Indeed, the principle of proportionality is an essential element in decision-making by public entities. It indicates that the administration of resources must be carried out with transparency, coherence, proportionality and responsibility, taking into account ethical principles such as autonomy, beneficence, non-maleficence and justice. In this way, it seeks to balance and weigh the principles involved, as well as consider the possible negative consequences in the exercise of public function (Hernández, 2019). Likewise, the principle of proportionality establishes that the answers provided must be in accordance with the good that is sought to be achieved and the damage that could be caused. 2.2 Proportionality check Control of proportionality can be defined as the control exercised by a court and which consists of specifically verifying that the application of a rule of domestic law does not give rise to a disproportionate violation of a fundamental right guaranteed by an international agreement or by a national rule in light of the legitimate purpose pursued by this rule (Hernández, 2019). When the fundamental right in question is guaranteed by the Human Rights Convention, the whole challenge of proportionality control, for the courts of the States party to the Convention. In summary, the proportionality control focuses on determining whether a challenged measure is appropriate and necessary to achieve the end pursued, avoiding excesses that may compromise the compromised evolution (Hernández, 2019). Although it has been criticized for its possible legal uncertainty and for favoring the expansion of the law, this control also has advantages by improving the judge's motivation and legitimacy. The principle of proportionality derives from the interpretation of the Fundamental Law, guaranteeing the protection of fundamental rights and defending the Rule of Law. It is important to remember that the control of proportionality requires that the acts of the institutions remain within appropriate and necessary limits to meet the objectives of the regulations in question. When there are several appropriate measures, the least restrictive one must be chosen and the inconveniences caused must not be disproportionate in relation to the purposes pursued (Hernández, 2019). For example, in the field of fines for antitrust infringements, the sanction imposed on a company must be proportional to the seriousness of the infringement as a whole. Currently, the use of proportionality control in administrative law is widely extended and is characterized by considering national differences in the operational performance of state entities. In addition, it helps to understand and organize this diversity, offering hypotheses about the sources of variation observed in the fields of public law (Hernández, 2019). Proportionality, according to Hernández (2019), ceases to be a limitation on efficiency and becomes a factor that improves it. By having a precise objective, proportionality does not derive from a restriction, as in the principle of necessity of criminal law, but is the result of the fact that any legal mechanism is a meaningful compliance tool in relation to a specific objective. . It is vitally important to establish clear objectives for compliance with the law, since it is in this area where the legal regulations related to said compliance are located, and control must be closely related to these objectives. In this context, the Constitutional Court has outlined the essential elements of the "Proportionality Test" through various rulings, such as C-133 of March 17, 1994, C-013 of January 23, 1997, C-022 of January 23, 1996, C-070 of February 22, 1996, C-213 of April 24, 1997. , C-087 of March 18, 1998, C-183 of May 6, 1998, C-010 of January 19, 2000, C-110 of February 9, 2000, C-093 of January 31, 2001, C-225 of March 30 and C-144 of April 6, 2015, among others. For example, in Judgment C-144/15 it was established; The principle of proportionality, understood as a course that seeks to balance two or more legal institutes that have come into contradiction, has been the subject of numerous developments both in national jurisprudence and in international doctrine and is currently established as a barrier to the imposition of limitations on fundamental rights and as a guarantee of their effectiveness (Plenary Chamber of the Constitutional Court, Judgment C-144, 2015, p.4). In relation to this procedure, the controversial doctrine on the normative structure of the proportionality test. Some authors understand it as a principle of constitutional interpretation, others as a legal norm and still others as a maximum. The terminology used does not seem to have great practical consequences for the normative structure of the proportionality test, but this terminological confusion can lead to conceptual inconsistencies that can be avoided. It is not intended to affirm that the term is better or worse, correct or incorrect, but only to adopt a concept that can be rationally based without great contradictions and without logical incoherence. In a timely manner, Judgment C-144/15 indicates; In short, and as constitutional jurisprudence has reiterated, the judge's duty when carrying out a proportionality test must take into account the recognized fundamental or essential elements such as; suitability, necessity and the proportionality test in the strict sense: Regarding the following elements: First: The suitability or adequacy of the measure refers to the fact that the actions of the state must guarantee the effectiveness of the legitimately claimed right; Second: Necessity is a fundamental element where the constitutional judge can verify whether the precautionary measure is beneficial or, on the contrary, it is excessive and consequently ends up violating the constitutionally protected higher-ranking fundamental rights. Third: The proportionality test in the strict sense, is the means by which it is pondered whether the restriction on fundamental rights that derive from the measure in question is equivalent to the benefits or is harmful, that is, it affects the interests constitutionally protected. (Constitutional Court, Judgment C-144, 2015, p.5). The application of the proportionality test in cases of collision of fundamental rights, starting from the premise that constitutional norms are the positive seat par excellence of such rights, guaranteeing them, in this step, hierarchical superiority and demanding normative force of measures that specify their content of being Regarding the step-by-step process of the proportionality test, it is possible to understand the differences in the use of this principle in the administrative law of various jurisdictions through three main axes of variation. In each jurisdiction, we can reflect on the following aspects: 1. The degree of use of proportionality: For example, if it is applied randomly, only in some specific cases or if it is a general review criterion that is applied to all administrative actions in principle (Hernández, 2019). 2. The intensity of the application of proportionality: For example, if it implies a rigorous judicial control, a substantial deference or if, in practice, it is a low-intensity reasonableness test (Hernández, 2019). 3. The degree of control of proportionality in the jurisdiction: For example, if the territorial entities of Cundinamarca consider proportionality as a reasoned justification framework through which they explain how they reach a conclusion based on relevant factors (Hernández, 2019). It is important to note that there are intermediate points between the extremes of each of these axes, and it should be noted that the use of proportionality in administrative law is not static, as it can constantly change in many legal systems. But ultimately it is possible to resolve some of the transnational variety we see into intelligible patterns, at which point some underlying regularities in the use of proportionality begin to emerge. Because proportionality is beginning to look like a kind of master concept of public law, found widely and also accommodating to multiple system- and context-specific differences: an illustration of unity in diversity. Surely, to be sure, the diversity is very real; not only in formal doctrinal structures, but even in what actors from the different legal systems mean when they refer to proportionality or balance (Hernández, 2019). The starting point is the comprehensive constitutional system of norms of fundamental rights of different structures, such as rules and principles, as well as other normative elements linked to them for their proper interpretation and application. Fundamental rights mutually limit themselves in harmonious coexistence in the constitutional system, but, by identifying different social interests and values, they entail a certain dialectical tension that requires harmonizing measures of interpretation and application of its norms, especially those with a structure of constitutional principles. The forms of concrete arguments are examples of this type of measures. Even so, there are cases of collision of fundamental rights in which the intersection of their scope of protection will require measures that establish, in a manner committed to the realization of the Constitution, a circumstantial and proportional origin. These are the so-called hard cases and give rise to a balance between related fundamental rights. The weighting, carried out through the application of the proportionality test, does not replace the requirements of constitutional interpretation, but is added as a logical reasoning mechanism to attribute relative weights to fundamental rights in situations of conditioned conflict . This process does not exclude a substantiated examination of the adequacy and necessity of the restrictive measure, that is, the concatenated and subsequent application of the partial examinations that make up proportionality in a broad sense. Taking into account the technical instrument that characterizes the correct application of the proportionality test, it can be said that it is a mechanism for the protection of fundamental rights that structures the application of the norms that enshrine them in order to respect the necessary promotion for the practical agreement. among them, relative to constitutional unity. The proportionality test, operationalized by the orderly application of its three partial elements of adequacy. Sentence C-916/02, indicated that; The Colombian proportionality trial is characterized by being conceived as a principle of interpretation that can take the form of mandates, indicating that these are understood how; the prohibition of excess and the prohibition of defect. The first has to do mainly with limiting the use of public power with regard to fundamental freedoms. The second is generally applied with respect to the positive duties of the State and the protection of rights that comprise the actions of the authorities for the fulfillment of the essential purposes of the State (Full Chamber of the Constitutional Court, Judgment C-916, 2002, p.9). In relation to the application of the principle of proportionality with the PPPs, Judgment C-269/21 suggests; In conclusion, the margin of legislative configuration in matters of private property is not absolute. On the contrary, it is circumscribed to the mandates that the State has to establish limitations to the right to property, among which is the obligation to justify the affectation of said right. Therefore, any limit or restriction to private property must be motivated by a specific purpose that is related to public utility, interest or its social and ecological functions. In this sense, imposing an affectation on the right to property without meeting these requirements implies an excess of the legislative configuration margin that will have to be analyzed in light of the principle of proportionality. Evaluation of the Projects of Public Private Association of Private Initiative. The originators of projects of Public Private Association of Private Initiative, will assume at their own expense and risk, the estimated cost of their review and/or evaluation in the feasibility stage. (Full Chamber of the Constitutional Court, Judgment C-269, 2021, p.1). In relation to this, the general image of the PPP is represented by the cooperation between public and private actors to carry out activities of public interest, cooperation based on the capacities of each partner to adequately allocate resources, risks and benefits. The main elements of the institutional framework are established by national legislation, therefore the traditional domains for the development of alliances are necessary at the national and infrastructure level. The increasing trend towards decentralization of service provision introduces many public-private opportunities such as health, education and other social services in non-traditional areas as well. At the community level, the interest in legislating aspects of public-private collaboration is based on offering a framework of principles and procedures so that governments can transpose them into national legislation, which includes public contracts or concessions, and is subject to directives on public contracts and the derived legislation on concessions and public-private collaborations, which must absolutely respect the principles of transparency, equal treatment, proportionality and mutual recognition. In relation to the method of the five justifications, England and Wales have been pioneers in the development of Public-Private Partnerships (PPP) since the beginning of the industrial revolution. During the Labor government from 1997 to 2010, the growth of the sector was promoted with the aim of increasing investment in national infrastructure without increasing public debt. To this end, various projects were supported that involved design, construction, financing, maintenance, operation, and concessions, mainly under the Private Financing Initiative (PFI) (Hodge and Greve, 2007). While many of these projects were successful, some high-profile failures, such as those related to the recent collapse of the construction and facilities management company, Carillion, and its aftermath, have raised questions about the outsourced services model that challenges the PPP The political perception in some quarters is that the private sector has made excessive profits without assuming proportional risk, which has led the government to reduce and restructure the PFI/PPP program in some cases. In addition, the low government borrowing ratio, coupled with the declining availability of long-term bank debt, has reduced some of the commercial incentive to use the PPP model as a means of delivery (Flinders, 2005). These changes led to reforms that addressed some criticisms of PFI/PPP and, as a result, the government introduced a greater emphasis on efficiency, transparency, and risk sharing. The modified PPP approach (Private Finance 2 (PF2)) which encourages, for example, a government to take a minority shareholding in the project company. Despite this, the Labor opposition made clear its opposition to PPPs in general, announcing its intention to end the use of the UK PFI/PPP model in some cases, making state-provided assets and services public ownership ( Mizell, 2018). Here arises the method known as the "five justifications", which operates as a voluntary code of conduct applicable to all Public-Private Partnerships (PPP) in which the signatories participate. This approach establishes commitments for both the public sector and private sector parties, with the purpose of ensuring constructive responsibility, flexibility and improvement of operational efficiency in their projects. Its main objective is to reflect best practices and should be thoroughly reviewed by new bidders interested in entering the sector. This method is part of the government's efforts to reduce the costs of PFI arrangements within the operational savings program, and has been developed with the support and participation of relevant trade bodies and a diverse set of lenders (Flinders, 2005). As described by the DNP (2021) in Colombia, an adaptation of the method applied to the phases of PPP Projects was carried out, as a Guide for the national territory, especially in the pre-contractual stage, the Ministry of Health (2018) explains; The competent state or private entity, depending on the origin of the PPP initiative, must carry out the pertinent studies for the formulation of the project, advance its process in accordance with the respective regulations, as well as the selection and contracting process. For the project, the competent state entity and the originator of the private initiative, as the case may be, must have a series of inputs and products for its structuring, which require a method for its support and presentation, among which is the Five Justifications (managerial, strategic, economic, financial and commercial) to start a PPP (p.24). It is important to note that, in the country, different government agencies may carry out their own programs, as long as they are largely aligned with the standard centralized approach. Some departments and sections have more developed programs adapted to their respective sectors, such as the Ministry of the Environment, Health, Education and Defense. These programs are fundamental to the topic of the thesis presented in this document, since they provide inputs and support for the requirements of the pre-feasibility and feasibility stages of the Public-Private Partnership (PPP) project. Figure 9 shows the strategic line promoted by the National Planning Department. The justification of the project focuses on identifying and addressing social needs, complying with the guidelines of the Government's public policies (DNP, 2021). Regarding the economic justification, it is highlighted that the cost-benefit study is the most appropriate option, since it provides a greater value for money (VpD). The term "value for money" (VpD) refers to the optimal combination of long-term cost and quality of goods, services, and assets to meet user needs. The VfD is defined as the choice in the effective composition between price-quality or cost-benefit (DNP, 2014). Said marginal benefit corresponds to the benefit that a company achieves when a marginal or additional unit is sold. Therefore, the marginal product refers to the additional revenue earned. Regarding the marginal cost, it refers to the expenses related to the production of an additional unit. The financial apology shows that the project is financially accessible to the people who are a bidder in said contract, public money will be used for possible setbacks, depending on what was agreed with the National Government (DNP, 2014). The DNP indicates how this viability can be known through sector and market studies, the main objective of the investigation is to mitigate the danger of failure, taking the best options in the market and in the long term. And with respect to the legal and commercial apology, it is identified when the project is in a viable state, that is, when in light of the market it is approved and the risks that it may have have been verified. At this point, the accounting treatment of the project is identified as serious (DNP, 2021). Any project that is executed to meet the client's requirements has to go through many phases, the multiple phases that are carried out during the project, but it is necessary with regard to the award of PPPs, guide processes before starting any project to increase the feasibility of the project. Here we are not talking about the gathering of requirements but the process that is being carried out before starting the project; called project feasibility analysis. Each project management team decides on a particular process or method that will be implemented for the viability of the project, but to promote the growth of PPPs in Colombia and in favor of the transparency of contracting, it is recommended to follow the method of five justifications (DNP , 2014). According to the DNP structure (2014), the first thing to do in the feasibility study of the project is to outline a plan, this gives you a vision of what the objective of your project is and in which areas your analysis should go. The neglected need, a market with more demand than supply, and the different advantages of the product or service must be concentrated when deciding the feasibility of the project. The most important thing to study are the obstacles in the way and their possible solutions. Various factors should also be considered when studying possible solutions to obstacles, such as being too expensive, not marketable, etc. The second and most important step for the project feasibility study is the financial retrospective study of the proposed project, and this is where the five justifications apply. Finances are the main concern in any project and there must be a good return on investment, therefore this step is of vital importance in the feasibility analysis process. In the first place, indicating what income is expected from the project and then what is the amount of the investment, it is important to study this to achieve the objective of the project and the feasibility of the project (Mizell, 2018). Investment costs include each individual service, its cost, income adjustments such as reimbursements, etc. This should also include any known, unknown, and surprising costs that may occur in the execution of the project. Once you have accurately performed the above steps of the project feasibility study, it is important to set up the organization and processes of the envisioned PPP (Wang et al., 2020). This step must include the initial cost, investments, including operating costs, said cost includes factors such as equipment, marketing methods, infrastructure, personnel, convenience of supply, among other aspects. This can also include any known and surprising costs that may occur during the implementation of the project. The standard process of the Public-Private Partnerships (PPP) cycle, according to the DNP PPP Guide (2014), involves an initial analysis of economic viability and an evaluation of the PPP in the identification and evaluation phase. Then follows a detailed evaluation of the project as a technical solution and as a PPP during the evaluation and preparation phase. This sequence is suitable for PPP programs motivated by the desire to use this modality as an alternative to public finance, speeding up infrastructure development (Hodge and Greve, 2007). In this context, the investment decision and the decision whether the project should be a PPP are closely related. If a project is not suitable to be a PPP, due to fiscal constraints, it may be necessary to carry it out as a traditional procurement project. Therefore, the DNP Guide (2014) highlights that it is essential to establish common ground for an adequate explanation of the PPP process, defining the different tasks and decisions to be made. The approach should be flexible in practice, as some analyzes and tasks may extend beyond the limits of the respective phases or require subsequent revisions. It is important to mention that the work in each phase is also influenced by the policy and the applicable legal framework. However, what is essential for the success of a PPP project, according to the DNP (2014), is to develop an appropriate technical solution and assess its feasibility as a PPP, adequately preparing the contract and the bidding process. In addition, the project must be contracted or offered effectively, complying with the applicable legal and regulatory requirements, and must be managed during its contractual life, in what is known as contract management (DNP, 2014). Contribution of Public-Private Associations to the development of the Department of Cundinamarca in light of the principle of proportionality in accordance with the method of the five justifications directed by the National Planning Department For more than a century, public-private partnerships have been common practice in the construction industry. Various arrangements have been used depending on the level of risk, ranging from public procurement to privatization. Since the 1990s, there has been a marked increase in the use of Public-Private Partnerships (PPPs) around the world, as governments in developed and developing countries turn to this method to address infrastructure deficits. Given the growing financial challenges in infrastructures at a global level, PPPs are presented as a valuable solution to overcome the financial and administrative limitations of the public sector. In a broad sense, PPPs represent a relationship between the private sector and public bodies, with the objective of incorporating resources and knowledge from the private sector to improve the provision of public goods and services. When addressing how Public-Private Partnerships contribute to the development of the Department of Cundinamarca, in line with the principle of proportionality and the method of the five justifications of the National Planning Department, it is important to take into account that with the natural development of this contracting modality, various variants of PPP models have been generated, such as alliances, groups, competitive associations, incremental associations, integrators and joint ventures, which respond to the specific challenges of different situations and sectors. The rapid growth of public-private collaboration in infrastructure has led to countries being at different stages of understanding and sophistication in the use of innovative collaboration models. It is essential to consider these variations and the continuous evolution in the field of PPPs to maximize their potential as a tool for development in the Department of Cundinamarca. Each country, and even each state and locality, follows its own path in the development of infrastructure PPPs. Many factors influence development, including local geography, political climate, capital market sophistication, the forces that drive association formation, and the factors that enable their creation. However, three distinct stages of PPP maturity can be observed around the world. This allows validating the hypothesis presented, since it was identified that the participation of Public-Private Associations by the Department of Cundinamarca promotes the development of the region by generating tools to improve administrative management and investment in infrastructure, which has a positive impact on basic sanitation and meeting the needs of communities. In Cundinamarca, as evidenced in Figure 2, which shows the entities with the largest number of projects registered in feasibility and pre-feasibility status in the Single Registry of Public-Private Associations ( RUA.PP ), there are 4 projects in pre-feasibility and 1 in feasibility. The Department ranks seventh out of eleven in territorial management by PPP, being the Cundinamarca Institute of Infrastructure and Concessions (ICCU) the promoter of the "Autopista Circunvalar de Occidente ACO" project. This project seeks to execute a new Circunvalar Highway in the West of Bogotá DC, connecting the metropolitan area of the city and distributing peripheral movements between different areas and nearby municipalities. The new proposed road starts north of the city of Bogotá, specifically at the Universidad de La Sabana junction, and continues to the East and South of Chía to connect with the Suba - Cota road. Then, it runs parallel to the Bogotá river to the west, connecting with route 80 to Medellín and the Bogotá - Funza road. Finally, the layout ends at the proposed intersection with the Bogotá - Girardot Highway, south of Soacha (Single Registry of Public-Private Associations, 2021, p.10). Despite this, the low number of PPP projects in the region does not respond to the needs identified by the Cundinamarca Infrastructure and Concessions Institute (ICCU) in Figure 10. This figure shows 25 categories prioritized by department leaders, which reflect deficiencies in basic community care. As the state crisis in social services has led to the development of public-private partnership models, there has been a systematic integration of private providers into the public sector. Partnerships between private companies and the government offer advantages to both parties; For example, private sector technology and innovation can improve operational efficiency and thus provide better public services. On the other hand, the public sector provides incentives for the private sector to deliver projects on time and within budget. In addition, creating economic diversification makes the country more competitive by boosting construction, equipment, and other associated businesses related to the infrastructure base. In this sense, the Department of Cundinamarca could consider, in light of the principle of proportionality and in accordance with the method of the five justifications that the National Planning Department guides, making Public-Private Associations a means to satisfy the needs of the communities. The proportionality test set forth by the Constitutional Court in Sentence C-470/2011 would be applied, as presented by González and Sanabria (2019), and shown in figure 11. As can be seen in figure 11, in the abstract application of the proportionality test, the indicators of purpose, suitability, necessity and proportionality were considered, analyzing the advantages and disadvantages. The principle of proportionality is important to consider, as some analysts argue that by diverting resources such as money and labor from market-driven to policy-driven purposes, PPPs hurt economic growth. However, advocates argue that the effective provision of public goods, such as education and roads, promotes economic growth. In turn, critics of PPPs say that the private sector could provide public goods more efficiently if it were not for the crowding-out effect of public distortions in capital markets. Therefore, here are some recommendations. The National Planning Department (DNP) must review the National Development Plan 2022-2026, "Colombia, World Power of Life", once it is approved, considering the sectors compiled in figure 12. In accordance with what is contemplated in the proportionality test, the lines of action must be involved to achieve modern governance and institutions, as well as efficient and safe transport and logistics. In addition, it should focus on sustainable urban and regional mobility to promote equity, competitiveness and quality of life. Other areas of interest include the development of strategic intermodal corridors, such as the national transportation network, logistics nodes, and modal efficiency. It is also important to promote innovation and financial mobilization of new payment sources to boost the development and implementation of the proposed initiatives. By accessing modernization plans, financing, training, and support, public officials will be able to reduce the net economic loss when making resource decisions for PPPs. Although public officials may be just as smart, capable, and well-meaning as their private-sector counterparts, the inability to make accurate social calculations can result in inefficiencies in policy decisions. In this process it is essential to define what type of PPP benefits the needs of the region, as shown in figure 13 in relation to the legislation, the PPP has some considerations that propose cooperation between public and private entities to carry out the provision of utility services. public, both parties having economic or social advantages. This is followed by defining the stages of the PPP maturity model for the region, as shown in Figure 13. This in turn will allow determining basic elements of the APP; contractual duration, compensation of private partners, risk of risk, financing of the company and transfer of control of the service. The summarized analysis of the political framework presented in the previous tables shows that the space to implement public-private responsibility is quite limited. Although the implementation of PPP projects is a complex process that requires adequate financial, human and time resources, as well as various documents or regulatory procedures, and to a lesser degree of transparency in the selection and execution of the PPP, in relation to this it is present some considerations. In order to apply the method of the 5 justifications to indicate that the PPPs would generate development in the Department, the following must be considered: General characteristics of public-private collaboration 1) Pacts 2) Relationship between partners 3) Obligations 4) Share risks and responsibilities 5) Continuity Specific characteristics of public-private collaboration 1) Typology 2) Service approach 3) Operating cost 4) Innovation 5) Risk allocation Assumptions of application of public-private collaboration 1) Political will 2) Appropriate legal framework 3) Suitability of the project 4) Suitable environment 5) Value for money 6) Legal certainty For the development of the Department and how that development would be reflected, the Department of Cundinamarca must consider that PPPs facilitate large projects, such as infrastructure, since the private sector has more agile means to carry them out, in addition to limiting the risk derived from delay , since the same sector incurs an obligation of result. Another exposed benefit is the contribution of money, achieved through the efficient allocation of risks. Furthermore, since the project is financed by the private sector, there is no reliance on public debt to do so. Finally, this project would also encourage new investment and minimize state costs. According to the Government of Cundinamarca (2021), there are several needs that require attention: 1. Construction of 14 schools in the department. 2. Intervention of 400 environments in school facilities. 3. Rehabilitation of irrigation districts. 4. Improvements in connection roads of the metropolitan area. 5. Equipment of urban and rural roads of municipalities. 6. Rehabilitation and routine maintenance of roads. According to the Program for the Consolidation of Private Participation Schemes in Infrastructure (PA.PP ) , the development and implementation of the PPPs involve several stages: structuring and evaluation of the PPP, design of the PPP contract and implementation of the PPP transaction. After this, the bidding process is opened and the request for fiscal guarantee and authorization of future validity by CONFIS. It is necessary to redirect the efforts in the Government entities, since, as previously mentioned, only the Cundinamarca Infrastructure and Concessions Institute (ICCU) has presented PPP. It would be advisable to train other entities, such as the Empresa Ferrea Regional SAS, Public Companies of Cundinamarca, FONDECUN, Departmental Institute of Culture and Tourism of Cundinamarca, Departmental Institute of Community Action, Departmental Institute for Recreation and the Sport of Cundinamarca, the Real Estate Company of Cundinamarca, Empresa Departamental Urbanística SAS and the Cundinamarca Cadastral Agency, so that they can also generate PPPs. Figure 15 provides some recommendations for this process. With respect to the general objective when analyzing how Public-Private Associations contribute to the development of the Department of Cundinamarca in light of the principle of proportionality in accordance with the method of the five justifications directed by the National Planning Department, PPPs always occur in the field of political economy because the contracting parties are not equal, one of the parties is a government or public entity and the other is a private entity. Governments change and so do policies. And in countries where the rule of law is not sufficiently established to maintain contract stability, investors see significant political risk that will need to be mitigated – this applies to contract termination, but also to payment risks. A main risk is regulatory, for example, the government's commitment to comply with a tariff law. Tariff adjustment can be highly political, particularly in election years, and therefore a private project can easily become politicized. Investors seek protection against such risks through guarantees, sometimes backed by a multilateral body, The public part also needs protection from the private partner. Private investors typically provide performance guarantees, sometimes parental guarantees that may be unlimited or limited. If the company does not deliver the product or service at the agreed level of quality or in the contracted time, if the building is not finished on time, if the water supply does not meet the specified safety levels, the government resorts to those guarantees . Here the proportionality of the sanctions with respect to the type of breach is important for the sustainability of the contract in the long term. But contracts should be governed primarily by incentives rather than penalties, giving both parties every reason to honor their obligations throughout the contract term. Regarding the specific objective of identifying the theoretical foundations of Public-Private Associations and their incidence in the Department of Cundinamarca. PPPs require many business development skills that need to be interdisciplinary, often attracting people with backgrounds in finance, economics, law, engineering, environment, accounting/tax, among others. Projects are moving slowly, first to establish sound engineering and economics, then financial and legal viability, and finally the political will to insert private sector participation. Private sector involvement usually introduces new governance rules in a sector, outsourcing previously hidden costs or processes. Therefore, these projects can arouse unions or specific interest groups and quickly become politicized. Without a government champion, PPPs are rarely successful. In either case, they require a lot of negotiation and consensus building to develop a common understanding of the project at each phase among the main stakeholders. It is common for contracts to include requirements that address the concerns of a multitude of stakeholders, and there is debate at every stage. In the later phases of a project, the private sector is invited to comment on draft contracts. In some cases, there are irresolvable differences (for example, the government's refusal to provide certain guarantees or unacceptable risk allocation) or special interests at stake, and projects fail. Environmental and social considerations are always important, but more critical on certain projects. For example, the construction of a road or a dam may require the resettlement of some families or communities and this may negatively affect the project, if not properly managed and addressed. In certain cases, these issues can become very, very complicated and politically challenging. Transparency, engagement with affected communities, and communication are key. As mentioned, to be successful in a PPP, a political leader is essential, it could be a key minister. In certain countries, it requires a firm commitment from the president of the country. It has to be someone who can attract stakeholders and who has the power to make decisions. Another critical key to success is the speed of a project, since they must be structured and awarded within a political cycle, and these are quite short, since governments change every four or five years. And something that is not always well understood is the issue of affordability for users and/or the government. Government projects are often over-designed or over-built so that capacity does not materialize in the medium term. The outsourcing of PPP costs often renders these projects unfeasible because they are not bankable without a substantial government subsidy. Therefore, when designing PPPs, special attention is paid to demand analysis and costing, so that a project is economically viable. We have many cases where we have proposed substantial design changes, such as reducing the footprint of an airport, changing the number of stations in a subway, among others. Part of why it's important to get things right from the beginning, with all the roles and risks clearly laid out in the contract, is because if there are problems, there is nothing more financially costly and politically embarrassing than discontinuing a PPP. Thus, with respect to the second specific objective, when determining what the principle of proportionality consists of, in accordance with the method of the five justifications directed by the National Planning Department, the principle of proportionality requires that national public authorities strike a fair balance between the public and private interests at stake, it means that a contracting authority has the obligation to strike a balance between the need to ensure that an adequate performance guarantee is provided for a contract and the interests of potential economic operators wishing to participate in a tender. And as for the third specific objective when establishing the contribution to the development of the Department of Cundinamarca of Public-Private Associations in light of the principle of proportionality in accordance with the method of the five justifications directed by the National Planning Department, there are no best practices that lead to standard legal clauses, but PPPs are specific. Each project is specific, even if it is in the same sector, and certain risks vary from country to country, all projects are very specific, the economy is specific, the political economy is specific, and the capacity and policies of the institutions, as well as the laws, are specific to a given country. Of course, there is a certain level of similarity within a sector, but a lot of difference between sectors. Very specifically, one would expect to see the development that APs would bring. For example, projects in airports and ports have a different risk profile than projects projects that involve natural monopolies, such as a water distribution system, energy distribution is much more competitive today, mainly with distributed generation. Certainly, there are environments where the risks make PPPs inadvisable due to the return that a private investor would require, the potential lack of bankability, and the likely lack of local capacity to manage complex contracts. So everything can be done, but it comes at a cost that is probably unreasonable. That starts a process where hopefully in the medium term the private sector can appreciate the track record of government institutions and operations that may be comfortable enough to justify a moderate level of investment. So, in fragile environments, it is necessary to be creative and design projects that allow the improvement of a sector with a view to possible future investments.

Identifiants

HANDLE
10901/25934

Repères documentaires

Famille documentaire
unknown
Types déclarés par les sources
UNKNOWN

Les mentions d’entités ne constituent pas une preuve de reconnaissance juridique. La juridiction étudiée est distincte du pays d’affiliation des auteurs.

Sources

OpenAIRE

    Source documentaire directe en cours de consolidation

    Citer cette référence

    vargas leyton, luis carlos; lugo labrador, laura patricia. aplicación de las asociaciones público-privadas en proyectos de infraestructura social en el departamento de cundinamarca (2021 – 2022). https://www.declarationuniverselledesdroitsdelarbre.org/global-rights-of-nature-radar/reference/r-cc0ca2f138518e728201670bda612875/

    JSON · CSL-JSON · BibTeX · RIS · CSV · JSON-LD ·

    APA, Chicago, ISO 690 : formats bibliographiques fondés sur les champs disponibles. OSCOLA / Bluebook : données structurées uniquement ; aucune conformité juridique complète n’est revendiquée sans vérification des éléments nécessaires.

    APA
    vargas leyton, luis carlos; lugo labrador, laura patricia. aplicación de las asociaciones público-privadas en proyectos de infraestructura social en el departamento de cundinamarca (2021 – 2022). https://www.declarationuniverselledesdroitsdelarbre.org/global-rights-of-nature-radar/reference/r-cc0ca2f138518e728201670bda612875/
    Chicago
    vargas leyton, luis carlos; lugo labrador, laura patricia. aplicación de las asociaciones público-privadas en proyectos de infraestructura social en el departamento de cundinamarca (2021 – 2022). https://www.declarationuniverselledesdroitsdelarbre.org/global-rights-of-nature-radar/reference/r-cc0ca2f138518e728201670bda612875/
    ISO 690
    vargas leyton, luis carlos; lugo labrador, laura patricia. aplicación de las asociaciones público-privadas en proyectos de infraestructura social en el departamento de cundinamarca (2021 – 2022). https://www.declarationuniverselledesdroitsdelarbre.org/global-rights-of-nature-radar/reference/r-cc0ca2f138518e728201670bda612875/

    Warning: Undefined array key "last_link_verified" in /home/clients/e27d81e12f04d2bfd747aa264540ac56/sites/_UDTR_APP/legal_library_reference.php on line 31

    UDTR — Bibliothèque juridique mondiale des droits de la Nature. aplicación de las asociaciones público-privadas en proyectos de infraestructura social en el departamento de cundinamarca (2021 – 2022). Notice documentaire: https://www.declarationuniverselledesdroitsdelarbre.org/global-rights-of-nature-radar/reference/r-cc0ca2f138518e728201670bda612875/ · Dernière vérification HTTP : non effectuée

    Signaler une correction

    Données de cette version figée

    Dossiers et relations documentaires

    Rôles des sources

    Un lien vers une autorité ne prouve pas à lui seul une affirmation juridique. Les résumés et les textes intégraux restent soumis aux conditions de leur source.

    Statut documentaire

    Pertinence à examiner

    Bibliothèque

    Cette identité n’est pas encore intégrée à la Bibliothèque juridique.

    UDTR — Bibliothèque juridique mondiale des droits de la Nature