Beyond Illegality and Admissibility: A Remedial Framework for Evaluating Unlawfully Obtained Evidence in Criminal Proceedings
Identification
- Clé publique
- radar:r-48a5292aa604af6bb5dbcadfbcf4fd8d
- Auteurs
- Pommier Gallo, Sergio
- Année déclarée
- 2026
- Langue déclarée
- en
- Type source
- Preprint
- Première détection
- 2026-11-13T08:38:27.145361+00:00
- Dernière observation des métadonnées
- 2026-11-13T08:38:27.145361+00:00
- Dernière vérification HTTP
- Non effectuée
Institutions déclarées par la source
Stanford University
Résumé documentaire — langue originale
The use of unlawfully obtained evidence presents criminal justice systems with a problem that cannot be resolved solely by determining whether a procedural or constitutional violation occurred. A second question follows: what legal consequence should attach to the violation, particularly when the evidence appears reliable and relevant to the determination of guilt? Different legal systems answer this question through exclusionary rules, discretionary admissibility assessments, remedial balancing, and alternative forms of accountability. These approaches reflect competing concerns involving individual rights, evidentiary reliability, deterrence, institutional legitimacy, and the public interest in adjudicating criminal charges. This article develops a remedial framework that distinguishes four dimensions of unlawful evidence: the nature of the violation, its relationship to the acquisition of the evidence, its effect on the fairness and integrity of proceedings, and the capacity of the proposed remedy to address the underlying wrong. Drawing on United States Supreme Court jurisprudence and the Canadian constitutional framework, it argues that the reliability of evidence and the legality of its acquisition must be evaluated as distinct questions. It further proposes that remedial decisions should identify the protected interest, examine the causal relationship between the violation and the evidence, assess the institutional incentives created by admission or exclusion, and explain why the selected remedy is proportionate to the violation. The article does not advocate automatic exclusion in every case or unrestricted admission whenever evidence appears trustworthy. Instead, it offers a structured method for avoiding the two opposite errors of treating every illegality as requiring an identical consequence and treating reliable evidence as sufficient justification for disregarding procedural violations.
Identifiants
- DOI
- 10.5281/zenodo.23568184
Repères documentaires
- Famille documentaire
- unknown
- Types déclarés par les sources
- Preprint
- Éditeurs
- Zenodo
Les mentions d’entités ne constituent pas une preuve de reconnaissance juridique. La juridiction étudiée est distincte du pays d’affiliation des auteurs.
Sources
DataCite · Document 1
Citer cette référence
Pommier Gallo, Sergio. Beyond Illegality and Admissibility: A Remedial Framework for Evaluating Unlawfully Obtained Evidence in Criminal Proceedings. 2026. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23568184
JSON · CSL-JSON · BibTeX · RIS · CSV · JSON-LD ·
APA, Chicago, ISO 690 : formats bibliographiques fondés sur les champs disponibles. OSCOLA / Bluebook : données structurées uniquement ; aucune conformité juridique complète n’est revendiquée sans vérification des éléments nécessaires.
- APA
- Pommier Gallo, Sergio. (2026). Beyond Illegality and Admissibility: A Remedial Framework for Evaluating Unlawfully Obtained Evidence in Criminal Proceedings. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23568184
- Chicago
- Pommier Gallo, Sergio. Beyond Illegality and Admissibility: A Remedial Framework for Evaluating Unlawfully Obtained Evidence in Criminal Proceedings. 2026. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23568184
- ISO 690
- Pommier Gallo, Sergio. Beyond Illegality and Admissibility: A Remedial Framework for Evaluating Unlawfully Obtained Evidence in Criminal Proceedings. 2026. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23568184
Warning: Undefined array key "last_link_verified" in /home/clients/e27d81e12f04d2bfd747aa264540ac56/sites/_UDTR_APP/legal_library_reference.php on line 31
UDTR — Bibliothèque juridique mondiale des droits de la Nature. Beyond Illegality and Admissibility: A Remedial Framework for Evaluating Unlawfully Obtained Evidence in Criminal Proceedings. Notice documentaire: https://www.declarationuniverselledesdroitsdelarbre.org/global-rights-of-nature-radar/reference/r-48a5292aa604af6bb5dbcadfbcf4fd8d/ · Dernière vérification HTTP : non effectuée
Données de cette version figée
Dossiers et relations documentaires
Rôles des sources
Source bibliographique / publication d’origine · https://zenodo.org/doi/10.5281/zenodo.23568184
Un lien vers une autorité ne prouve pas à lui seul une affirmation juridique. Les résumés et les textes intégraux restent soumis aux conditions de leur source.
Statut documentaire
Pertinence à examiner
Bibliothèque
Cette identité n’est pas encore intégrée à la Bibliothèque juridique.