Beyond Viral Detection: How Weather and Sanitation Systems Shape the Epidemiological Interpretation of SARS-CoV-2 Wastewater Surveillance
Identification
- Public canonical key
- radar:r-84c6e8e800edc3bccefd5cd7bc87d70d
- Authors
- Kouassi Julien Momou
- Reported year
- 2026
- Reported language
- und
- Source type
- StudyRegistration
- First detected
- 2026-11-13T08:57:03.021712+00:00
- Last metadata observation
- 2026-11-13T08:57:03.021712+00:00
- Last HTTP verification
- Not checked
Documentary abstract — original language
S2 File. Retrospective methods record for the evidence map underlying the critical review (not a registration) RETROSPECTIVE RECORD, NOT A REGISTRATION. This record was compiled after searching, screening and charting were complete. It carries no registration number and is archived on the Open Science Framework (https://osf.io/r24aw). It documents the eligibility criteria, searches and methods as they were applied and discloses where they departed from the original plan. Beyond Viral Detection: How Weather and Sanitation Systems Shape the Epidemiological Interpretation of SARS-CoV-2 Wastewater Surveillance. Short title: Weather, sanitation and wastewater signal interpretation. 1. Administrative information • Start date: 8 March 2026 (first database search). • Timeline: first database search 8 March 2026; database searches, including the staged Boolean queries and hand-search, no later than 3 August 2026, and the PubMed re-verification on 4 August 2026 (publications to 31 July 2026; exact dates by database were not logged, see S3 File section 13); screening 18 May–26 June; charting 27 June–10 July; African Journals Online (AJOL) export 1 October 2026; AI-assisted retrieval (LeapSpace) 2 October 2026; dedicated PubMed and Google Scholar searches 5 October 2026; Scopus and Google Scholar selection and charting of verification records 7 October 2026; focused PubMed searches and database searches, 12 October 2026; consolidated single-string PubMed query run on 18 October 2026 (S3 File section 0). Search windows are therefore two: core searches (publications 1 December 2019 to 31 July 2026) and October 2026 components (no end date other than the search date). • Stage of review when this record was written: complete for all components up to 12 October 2026. The record does not meet the requirement of prospective registration and is declared as retrospective, in line with JBI and PRISMA-P guidance on retrospective records. The OSF project holds the original deposit and its version history with the date of each deposit; amendments are listed in section 7. • Review lead and corresponding author: Kouassi Julien Momou, Centre Hospitalier et Universitaire de Bouaké, Côte d’Ivoire (momoujulien@yahoo.fr). Second review (double screening of all components and verification of extraction): Prof. Dr. Chantal Akoua-Koffi and the Laboratory of Biology team, Centre Hospitalier et Universitaire de Bouaké (acknowledged, not authors). • Funding: none specific. Competing interests: none declared. Collaborators: none. 2. Review questions In human populations and the wastewater or sanitation systems serving them (Population), in any setting (Context): (1) Which weather, wastewater-based epidemiology (WBE) and sanitation-related studies (Concept) exist for SARS-CoV-2? (2) How are they distributed by design, country and World Bank income group? (3) Where is evidence missing, particularly for low- and middle-income countries (LMICs)? The work began as a systematic review with narrative synthesis; it was reframed as a scoping review and evidence map following JBI guidance, and is reported with PRISMA-ScR (S1 Checklist) and PRISMA-S. The evidence map then served as the evidence base for a critical review of how weather and sanitation systems shape the interpretation of wastewater signals; its four analytical questions (weather and the signal, signal and circulation, comparability across settings, interpretation) are stated in Section 1 of the review. 3. Eligibility criteria (population, concept, context) • Population: human populations and the wastewater or sanitation systems serving them. Context: any setting; income group recorded for the study setting. • Concept: SARS-CoV-2 or COVID-19 and at least one domain: (1) meteorological or flood variables in relation to incidence or transmission; (2) SARS-CoV-2 in wastewater or environmental water, with methods and programmes; (3) SARS-CoV-2 in sanitation systems, wastewater or surface water, or exposure to sanitation facilities, with an association, risk estimate or model. • Operational definitions. Weather: temperature, humidity, rainfall or precipitation, wind, ultraviolet radiation, season and flooding. WBE matrices: raw or treated wastewater, sewage, effluent and environmental water (rivers, canals, drains, stormwater, septic tanks); targets: SARS-CoV-2 RNA and variants, including methods and programmes. Sanitation-related risk: SARS-CoV-2 in sanitation systems, or exposure to toilets, latrines, shared facilities or open defecation, with an association, risk estimate or model. • Outcome domains recorded: incidence or reproduction number (Re), detection rate, lead time before clinical cases, variant detection and estimated infection risk. These domains were applied at full-text screening of the core search without having been published; they are now given in S4 Table Part F. • Sources: primary studies (observational, modelling including QMRA, laboratory persistence studies), reviews, perspectives and methodological papers. • Excluded: sources not specific to SARS-CoV-2; studies of water, sanitation and hygiene access or behaviour without environmental SARS-CoV-2 data or a sanitation-exposure estimate; transmission models without an environmental or wastewater component; clinical case reports without environmental components; animal-only studies; retracted articles; commentaries without an abstract. 4. Searches • Databases: PubMed/MEDLINE, Cochrane Library, Epistemonikos; English language (applied for feasibility, according to the reading capacity of the team), 1 December 2019 to 31 July 2026 for the core search (English-language database component: PubMed 15,374 + Cochrane Library 8 + Epistemonikos 616 = 15,998 records, of which 108 were retained and 49 included; the five core components together yielded 128 sources, S3 File section 10). The PubMed/MEDLINE string was: (("SARS-CoV-2"[tiab] OR "COVID-19"[tiab] OR coronavirus[tiab]) AND (climate[tiab] OR temperature[tiab] OR humidity[tiab] OR seasonal*[tiab] OR weather[tiab])) OR ((virus terms) AND (wastewater[tiab] OR sewage[tiab] OR effluent[tiab]) AND (surveillance[tiab] OR epidemiology[tiab] OR monitoring[tiab] OR detection[tiab])) OR ((virus terms) AND (wastewater[tiab] OR sewage[tiab] OR sanitation[tiab] OR "open defecation"[tiab]) AND ("risk assessment"[tiab] OR QMRA[tiab] OR exposure[tiab])). The strings of all databases as run, with record counts, and those of the language-filtered, dedicated, Google Scholar, AJOL, LeapSpace and Scopus components are in S3 File. • Refinement component (post hoc): staged queries in PubMed (504,013 records for virus terms alone; 14,333 with the climate, wastewater or surveillance cluster; 225 for the intersection; 11 for the three-cluster intersection; 43 useful articles overall), Scopus (112 records, 2 useful) and Web of Science (1,000 display-capped records, 111 retained, 49 useful), run with the same three-cluster structure as the core string (full strings: Scopus 2,731, Web of Science 1,000 and Global Index Medicus 99 records; S3 File section 8), cluster-restricted searches, confirmatory checks in Cochrane Library and Epistemonikos (no additional eligible records) and hand-search of Google Scholar, WHO publications and the Nature and Lancet portfolios. After removing five overlaps with the core component, it contributed 37 new sources. • PubMed re-verification (4 August 2026): a pool of 505 records saved (506 reported at retrieval), 38 examined on title and abstract, 28 added, plus one source (Meng 2021) at the final re-check; the first 10,000 of 519,577 virus-term records were also examined. Three PubMed searches restricted by publication language (4,753 records; 958 examined; 10 included) and a hand-search (about 15 records; 7 examined; 3 included). • Post hoc components added when early results showed few LMIC sources: citation searching; a targeted Google Scholar search for African and independent-network studies; an AJOL export (2,481 references); an AI-assisted retrieval of highly cited references (LeapSpace). • Supplementary documents (October 2026): an author-compiled list of 14 African WBE articles, two PubMed exports whose query strings were not saved, and full-text compilations (49 unique documents; S3 File). • Dedicated searches (5 October 2026, PubMed, no date or language limits): SARS-CoV-2 AND (flood* OR "heavy rain*" OR cyclone* OR "extreme precipitation") (271 records); SARS-CoV-2 AND (latrine* OR "open defecation" OR "on-site sanitation" OR "faecal sludge" OR "shared sanitation" OR WASH) (382 records); Google Scholar filter on the same themes (65 records, eight full texts read). • Database searches (12 October 2026): Web of Science, Scopus, Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews, Epistemonikos, Springer Nature and Google Scholar, each searched once with database-specific strings (S3 File). 407 records in ten files; 294 unique; 235 screened on title and abstract by two reviewers with AI assistance; 64 included. • Focused PubMed searches (12 October 2026): SARS-CoV-2 terms combined with weather, wastewater, sanitation, risk, income and region terms (publication from 1 December 2019; no language or article-type limit). 2,536 unique records; 424 screened on title and, where unclear, abstract; 116 included. All strings are subsets of one consolidated query (S3 File section 0, S8 File). • Scopus and Google Scholar selection (7 October 2026): string in S3 File; 16 documents supplied, 14 new, 1 included. Verification records not previously charted: 8 retrieved by the search-verification exercise, of which 7 were charted from titles and references and 1 (Zhao 2026) was not charted because its setting could not be verified (S5 File). • Peer review of search strategies: no formal PRESS review and no systematic consultation of a librarian or information specialist took place; the team built and iterated the strings and corrected them after execution (S3 File section 13). 5. Selection and charting as conducted • Core component: a title and abstract relevance filter was applied manually by the first reviewer using a conservative union rule, then full-text assessment. The filter was validated on 300 general SARS-CoV-2 records drawn from a pool of 3,800; one record (0.33%; 95% CI 0.06–1.86%) was a plausibly eligible study not captured. This is a miss rate on general records, not a recall estimate; the later re-verification added 28 sources to the 86 found earlier. The reasons for the 59 full-text exclusions were not recorded at the time and could not be reconstructed (S4 Table Part B). • A second reviewer double-screened all components, including those of 12 October and the later additions (Google Scholar equity-driven search, citation searching, AJOL, LeapSpace, the Scopus and Google Scholar selection), and validated the first reviewer’s decisions; disagreements were resolved by consensus. The second reviewers are Prof. Dr. Chantal Akoua-Koffi and the Laboratory of Biology team, with the same AI assistance as the first reviewer. The second reviewer also verified extraction for all components. The second reviewer confirmed all 424 PubMed records screened on title and abstract; this confirmation was not independent of the AI proposals, so no agreement statistic is reported. Second decisions for the 1,972 set-aside records were not itemised (S8 File, Summary). Both reviewers worked from the same AI-assisted proposals, so this agreement is not independent of them; the recall of the AI-assisted triage of the dedicated searches and of the 1,972 set-aside records was not measured, and a fully independent re-screening of a random sample was not performed before submission. The 27 inclusion and exclusion decisions of the Google Scholar equity-driven search were re-read by a second reviewer on 18 October 2026 (27 of 27 identical; no source added or removed; S3 File section 11). • Records from the dedicated searches (709 after removing nine duplicates) were triaged on titles and abstracts by the first reviewer with the help of Claude; 106 were examined in detail (S5 File, sheet “Dedicated searches”), and the 48 included sources were confirmed by the second reviewer. The 603 exclusions were validated by the second reviewer, and the recall of the triage was not measured. • Focused PubMed records of 12 October: screened by two reviewers on title and, where unclear, abstract with AI assistance. The 1,972 records outside the targeted terms were examined with AI assistance and set aside after validation by both reviewers. Title-level reason codes were assigned by rule and their reliability was not measured. Keyword rules ordered the records and excluded none. A random audit of 88 set-aside records estimated the share of eligible records left out (S8 File). • Charted for each source: domain, design category, country or scope, income group (World Bank, fiscal year 2027) and region. Charting was by the first reviewer, from full texts, abstracts, titles or retrieval summaries (reading level, where recorded, in S5 File). Publications from one cohort or programme carry a shared label in S5 File. Reading level: full text 21 sources; title, abstract or retrieval summary 250; not recorded 148 (S5 File). Publication year was added to S5 File for all sources; S6 Table gives design, country, income group and reading level for E001–E419 and main findings for E163–E419 only. 6. Appraisal and synthesis No critical appraisal score or certainty rating is reported. For the critical review, a design-based appraisal states what each study design can and cannot support (Table 3 of the review), and four title-level indicators were added to the coding as descriptive counts, not compared between income groups (S5 File, sheets Interpretation coding, Interpretation rules and Interpretation summary; Table S6 and Fig. S3 in S9 File). Risk-of-bias and GRADE-adapted ratings prepared for the earlier systematic-review version were set aside when the work was reframed and are not part of this submission. Results are summarised as counts by design, income group, region and domain (formulas in S5 File) and as a narrative of findings as reported, without pooling. A random-effects meta-analysis of wastewater positivity was considered and not performed because comparable sample-level data were extractable for only one source. Critical appraisal is optional in JBI scoping reviews and was omitted because the aim was to map the distribution of evidence, not to judge its quality; instruments such as EMBRACE-WBE (wastewater studies) or a confounding checklist (ecological studies) could be applied in a later synthesis. Gaps were identified after charting, without a pre-defined matrix: a cell is called empty when it holds no source. No stakeholders were consulted, and the equity analysis is limited to World Bank income group. 7. Departures from the original plan Amendments to the original plan (dates are those recorded; the reframing date was not recorded). Date Change Justification Impact on records already screened After core screening and charting (by 4 August 2026) Reframed from a systematic review to a scoping review and evidence map; risk-of-bias and GRADE-adapted components removed; relevance filter validated post hoc. Aim of mapping rather than appraising evidence. None: no record was re-screened. Before 5 October 2026 (AJOL export 1 October; LeapSpace 2 October) Post hoc components added: Google Scholar equity-driven search, citation searching, AJOL export (1 October), LeapSpace (2 October). Early results showed few LMIC sources. None for earlier components; 35 sources added. 5 October 2026 Dedicated PubMed and Google Scholar searches; observational epidemiological design category added; eligibility extended to exposure to sanitation facilities with an association, risk estimate or model. To test the gaps in flooding and sanitation-related risk. The extension widened eligibility, so no earlier inclusion was removed; earlier components were not re-screened under it. The sanitation search found 38 eligible sources. 7 October 2026 Scopus and Google Scholar selection; charting of verification records. Search-verification exercise. Two records already charted; one added from the selection. 12 October 2026 Focused PubMed searches, targeted screening by keyword rules and database searches; article-type and income filters not retained. The consolidated single PubMed query was prepared on this date and run on 18 October 2026. To repeat the PubMed searches as one query and to target LMIC-relevant records. Earlier sources were not re-screened; 140 PubMed records and 59 database records were already charted. 15 October 2026 Evidence map used as the evidence base for a critical review; conceptual framework, design-based appraisal and title-level indicators added; no change to eligibility or searches. To analyse how weather and sanitation systems shape the interpretation of wastewater signals, as the analysis rather than the map was the aim of the submission. None: no record was re-screened or re-charted. 16 October 2026 Title changed (inequalities and income settings removed); LMIC defined as low-, lower-middle- and upper-middle-income; between-group comparisons of title-level indicators removed from the main text and kept as descriptive counts (Table S6, Fig. S3); statements that no study addressed a question qualified as referring to sources read at title and abstract level; propositions restated with refutation criteria; S6 Table extended to E001–E419; no change to eligibility, searches or charting. To match the claims to a non-random corpus, title-level coding and screening agreement that was not independent of the AI proposals. None: no record was re-screened or re-charted. 18 October 2026 Pre-submission checks. Consolidated PubMed query (S3 File section 0) run once as a single string (22,199 records; yearly exports 2020–2026 and query string archived on OSF). Second human re-reading of the 27 Google Scholar equity-driven decisions and of the flagged titles of the interpretation indicators (8/8, 8/8, 23/27, 19/20). Twelve verification records checked one by one against their titles and abstracts (PubMed or institutional records): no source removed; Zhao 2026 remains not charted because its setting is not stated; the retrieval summary received for Eryildiz-Yesir 2025 described a different article (favipiravir removal in a membrane bioreactor) and was not used, the charted record (E232) being the Istanbul surveillance study. Sensitivity of income-group counts to the study year checked for Costa Rica, the Philippines and Viet Nam (S5 File, Notes; S9 File, Table S3 note). To confirm the records and to document searches and checks that the earlier version left open. None: no record was re-screened, added or removed; counts unchanged. The 22,199 records of the consolidated query were archived and not screened. Use of generative AI and dissemination Claude (Anthropic) assisted with language editing, with the title and abstract triage of the dedicated searches and with restructuring the work as a critical review; both reviewers reviewed its proposals, but its recall was not formally validated. LeapSpace (Elsevier) was used only to retrieve candidate references, which were checked against their bibliographic records (S3 File section 12); the AJOL export was compiled without AI tools. Dissemination. Submission to Water Research; data and records on the Open Science Framework.
Identifiers
- DOI
- 10.17605/osf.io/xa28e
- URL
- https://osf.io/xa28e
Documentary context
- Documentary family
- unknown
- Source-reported types
- StudyRegistration
- Publishers
- OSF Registries
Entity mentions are not evidence of legal recognition. Jurisdiction studied is separate from author affiliation country.
Sources
DataCite · Record 1
Cite this reference
Kouassi Julien Momou. Beyond Viral Detection: How Weather and Sanitation Systems Shape the Epidemiological Interpretation of SARS-CoV-2 Wastewater Surveillance. 2026. https://doi.org/10.17605/osf.io/xa28e
JSON · CSL-JSON · BibTeX · RIS · CSV · JSON-LD ·
APA, Chicago, ISO 690: bibliographic formats using available fields. OSCOLA / Bluebook: structured data only; full legal citation compliance is not claimed without verification of required elements.
- APA
- Kouassi Julien Momou. (2026). Beyond Viral Detection: How Weather and Sanitation Systems Shape the Epidemiological Interpretation of SARS-CoV-2 Wastewater Surveillance. https://doi.org/10.17605/osf.io/xa28e
- Chicago
- Kouassi Julien Momou. Beyond Viral Detection: How Weather and Sanitation Systems Shape the Epidemiological Interpretation of SARS-CoV-2 Wastewater Surveillance. 2026. https://doi.org/10.17605/osf.io/xa28e
- ISO 690
- Kouassi Julien Momou. Beyond Viral Detection: How Weather and Sanitation Systems Shape the Epidemiological Interpretation of SARS-CoV-2 Wastewater Surveillance. 2026. https://doi.org/10.17605/osf.io/xa28e
Warning: Undefined array key "last_link_verified" in /home/clients/e27d81e12f04d2bfd747aa264540ac56/sites/_UDTR_APP/legal_library_reference.php on line 31
UDTR Global Rights of Nature Legal Library. Beyond Viral Detection: How Weather and Sanitation Systems Shape the Epidemiological Interpretation of SARS-CoV-2 Wastewater Surveillance. Documentary record: https://www.declarationuniverselledesdroitsdelarbre.org/global-rights-of-nature-radar/reference/r-84c6e8e800edc3bccefd5cd7bc87d70d/ · Last HTTP verification: not performed
Research dossiers and documentary relations
Source roles
Bibliographic / original publication source · https://osf.io/xa28e/
An authority link alone does not verify a legal claim. Abstracts and full texts remain subject to their source terms.
Documentary status
Relevance pending
Library
This identity is not yet included in the Legal Library.