AtlantECO Deliverable - D03.2 - Pluralistic valuation of ecosystem services
Identification
- Public canonical key
- radar:r-3fd07f62cc7b3fec353b4e075297ea7a
- Authors
- Sebastián Villasante · Gillian B. Ainsworth · Antía Campos · Andrés Ospina‐Álvarez · Francesco Bosello · Simone Libralato · Serena Zunino · Diana Lorena Rico-Velez · Donata Melaku Canu · Jamie D. Wilson · Anna Katavouta
- Reported year
- 2026
- Reported language
- en
- Source type
- article
- First detected
- 2026-11-14T02:02:48.590824+00:00
- Last metadata observation
- 2026-11-14T02:02:48.590824+00:00
- Last HTTP verification
- Not checked
Institutions reported by the source
Universidade de Santiago de Compostela · Xunta de Galicia · Ca' Foscari University of Venice · CMCC Foundation - Euro-Mediterranean Center on Climate Change · National Institute of Oceanography and Applied Geophysics · Euro Mediterranean University · University of Liverpool · National Oceanography Centre
Reported affiliation countries
ES · GB · IT · SI
Documentary abstract — original language
This deliverable contains a comprehensive evaluation of selected ecosystem services provided by ocean ecosystems under critical pressures based on research conducted in Task 3.2 Socio-cultural and economic valuation of ecosystem services. CMCC conducted an economic evaluation of provisioning and other serviceslinked to fishery, aquaculture, bio-prospecting, renewable energy and tourism activity by inspecting nationalstatistics to highlight their contribution to the production of national GDP (Section 4). USC (leading) coordinated the task and conducted a socio-cultural evaluation of cultural services with UIB-CSIC (Section 5).OGS conducted a quantification of regulating services to support these economic and socio-cultural evaluations including an assessment of carbon sequestration services of the Atlantic Ocean (Section 6) andan assessment of sequestration services from accumulation rates and stocks regarding coastal Atlantic bluecarbon ecosystems (Section 7). Overall, the deliverable addresses the lack of scientific knowledge in analyticalframeworks for effective policy-making to achieve sustainable environmental management. In Section 4, CMCC collated the available data on the economic values of provisioning services from capturefisheries, aquaculture, minerals, non-renewable/renewable energy, and coastal tourism, focusing on thematerial goods traded in markets that originated from marine ecosystems for which market prices exist andthat can be used as an indicator for the estimate of the value of the ecosystem service. We calculated themonetary value of marine provisioning services provided by capture fisheries, aquaculture, minerals,non-renewable/renewable energy and coastal tourism attributable to the Atlantic sea basin. Our results demonstrate that coastal tourism provides the highest Gross Value Added (GVA) (US$) for mostcountries among the sectors analysed, while fisheries and aquaculture generally provide the lowest, althoughthe contributions vary enormously across countries. Low-income Atlantic African countries tend to receiveGVA benefits from fisheries and sometimes from minerals and non-renewables. Conversely, the wealthiestcountries in temperate areas receive GVA benefits from tourism. In Section 5, USC and UIB-CSIC evaluated cultural ecosystem services, focusing on the conservation, andtourism and recreation sectors to understand the (dis)benefits provided by marine protected areas and marinetourism sites to visitors through practices associated with cultural, spiritual and historical heritage, provisionof nature-based recreation, and creation of opportunities for science and education. We selected 23 iconicmarine sites that are geographically distributed around the coastlines, islands and high seas and thatrepresent various biogeographic provinces and ecoregions throughout the Atlantic Ocean. We collected andanalysed data derived from 6,319 Google Maps reviews pertaining to these sites to identify the socio-culturalvalues held for each site individually and collectively. We also analysed visitor data and entrance fees tocalculate tourism revenue raised by each site. Reviewers reported almost 80 different kinds of pursuits, mostly relating to recreational activities underliningthe importance of marine areas for providing opportunities for people to play and exercise. Reviewers weremostly satisfied with their visits, with 90% of remarks being positive and sites receiving an average ratingscore of 4.7 out of a possible 5. Reviewers mostly appreciated Sense of Place, Tourism & Recreation,Livelihoods & Economies, Biodiversity and Clean Waters, as well as ‘clean site’. However, 10% of reviews werecomposed of negative remarks and reviewers identified various disbenefits received from the sites including:experiencing overcrowding of tourists, presence of marine litter on land and in the ocean, unsatisfying wildlifeinteractions, degraded environments, poor infrastructure or services, and high entrance fees. Our analysis also identified perceptions about the impacts of plastics on cultural services. These mainly relatedto the presence of plastics spoiling reviewers’ recreational activities such as enjoying scenic beauty (aestheticappreciation). These plastics were sometimes said to be found in the ocean (Clean Waters) but were mostlydescribed as being on beaches or nearby areas (Sense of Place - Lasting Special Places: clean site). Weuncovered that 18 of the 23 iconic sites distributed around the Atlantic Ocean were facingsocio-environmental threats at the time of our analysis. These threats were caused by local human activities,anthropogenic impacts, or climate changes and over half of the sites were perceived as suffering from multiplekinds of threats. The numerous and diverse wellbeing benefits received by site reviewers and our estimate of annual visitorrevenue of nearly US$207 million reveal the extent of public desire to visit iconic marine sites and awillingness to pay for cultural services provided by healthy sites. This also hints at the amount of public fundsfor site management, conservation and promotion that could be lost should all tourists avoid these sites dueto the significant threats we identified. In Section 6, OGS, Univ. Liverpool and NOC investigated the regulating services of the ocean’s carbonsequestration process, focusing on the biological carbon pump (BCP), which accounts for about 70% of theocean's carbon sequestration capacity. We estimated the carbon storage for the Atlantic Ocean by applyingtwo methods. First, we applied a method based on model assessments of Particulate Organic Carbon (POC)fluxes and of mineralization of POC. We assessed the carbon flux of POC at 1000 m depth and the inventoryof sequestered carbon using data from three Earth system models (ESM) at the present time. Second, weapplied a method that integrates the contribution of gravitational, migrant and mixing pumps, using modelsand observations to quantify carbon export and sequestration through the ocean's BCP. From the three different ESM models we estimated the total amount of POC that reaches 1000 m in theAtlantic Ocean varies between 0.47 PgCy-1 and 0.18 PgCy-1. We identified that the Atlantic Ocean exhibitsdifferent patterns of carbon flux into the deep sea that vary with the latitudinal gradient. Low carbon export isparticularly evident in the subtropical gyres while the tropical and upwelling areas are characterized by higherproductivity. The North Atlantic is another region with high carbon exports whereas the Southern Ocean is thezone where the models are more uncertain, however, high carbon export in the sub-Antarctic region is stillevident due to the highly productive spring bloom. By shifting the focus from fluxes to inventory stock, thisassessment provides a more comprehensive understanding of the processes themselves and their long-termcontribution to ocean carbon sequestration. The Csoft, which represents the total carbon stored in theAtlantic as an average among the 3 ES Models is 310.72 PgC, which represents 17% of the global carbonsequestration. We also conducted an economic valuation of the benefits of the Atlantic ecosystems in relation to theircarbon storage services using the concept of Social Cost of Carbon (SCC) which measures the damage cost ofemitting an additional unit of carbon dioxide or other equivalent greenhouse gases into the atmosphere.Three factors are particularly relevant in determining the social cost of carbon: how damages are aggregatedintra-temporally across different individuals, groups or communities; when the unit emission occurs; andchoice of discount rate. The total carbon stock of the Atlantic is in the order of 260-375 PgC (average 319.49PgC; about 15-20% of the global ocean carbon stock), with the average value of this output estimated atbetween US$46.6 trillion to US$171 trillion. In Section 7, OGS assessed regulating services based on an analysis of blue carbon sequestration fromaccumulation rates and stocks of ‘blue carbon ecosystems’ (BCE) in the Atlantic Ocean. These include habitatssuch as salt marshes, tidal flats, seagrass meadows and mangroves which can provide important climateregulating services as nature-based solutions to mitigate climate change by achieving carbon removal from theatmosphere. We calculated carbon storage at the Atlantic scale by analysing the global databases of BCEhabitats to determine their spatial extent then converting their extension to carbon accumulation rates andcarbon storage for each ecosystem through coefficients extracted from literature. We identified that the total area of BCEs in the Atlantic is 273,600 km². Seagrass has the largest extent,covering 54% of this area, with a total of 145,814.92 km². Tidal flats have an extension of 42,719.5 km2 representing 15% of the BCE area in the Atlantic, and 19.52% of the global extent. Mangroves cover57,420.60 km² in the Atlantic Ocean, representing 21.95% of the area and 41.73% of the global extent, whilesalt marshes are the least extended BCE in the Atlantic Ocean, covering 28,399.54 km², representing 10.57%of the Atlantic basin and 68.18% of the global extent. The total carbon accumulation rate in the Atlantic isestimated to be 46.81 TgCy-1 , while the total carbon stock, which represents the total carbon sequesteredbelow-ground in Atlantic coastal ecosystems, is estimated to be 4.5 PgC, which represents 44 % of the globalCstock estimates (7.6 PgC). However, these ecosystems are heavily impacted by human activities. All BCE have declined over the lastcentury, mainly due to aquaculture, land-use change and land reclamation. Given increasing attention to thistopic, many efforts have been made to produce accurate estimates of global BCE. Significant uncertaintypersists since the available distributional data is highly skewed geographically (and historically) and manycomponents required to conduct complete assessments are lacking.
Identifiers
- OPENALEX
- https://openalex.org/W7154207095
- DOI
- 10.5281/zenodo.19569842
Documentary context
- Documentary family
- article
- Source-reported types
- article
Entity mentions are not evidence of legal recognition. Jurisdiction studied is separate from author affiliation country.
Sources
OpenAlex · Record 1
Cite this reference
Sebastián Villasante; Gillian B. Ainsworth; Antía Campos; Andrés Ospina‐Álvarez; Francesco Bosello; Simone Libralato; Serena Zunino; Diana Lorena Rico-Velez; Donata Melaku Canu; Jamie D. Wilson; Anna Katavouta. AtlantECO Deliverable - D03.2 - Pluralistic valuation of ecosystem services. 2026. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.19569842
JSON · CSL-JSON · BibTeX · RIS · CSV · JSON-LD ·
APA, Chicago, ISO 690: bibliographic formats using available fields. OSCOLA / Bluebook: structured data only; full legal citation compliance is not claimed without verification of required elements.
- APA
- Sebastián Villasante; Gillian B. Ainsworth; Antía Campos; Andrés Ospina‐Álvarez; Francesco Bosello; Simone Libralato; Serena Zunino; Diana Lorena Rico-Velez; Donata Melaku Canu; Jamie D. Wilson; Anna Katavouta. (2026). AtlantECO Deliverable - D03.2 - Pluralistic valuation of ecosystem services. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.19569842
- Chicago
- Sebastián Villasante; Gillian B. Ainsworth; Antía Campos; Andrés Ospina‐Álvarez; Francesco Bosello; Simone Libralato; Serena Zunino; Diana Lorena Rico-Velez; Donata Melaku Canu; Jamie D. Wilson; Anna Katavouta. AtlantECO Deliverable - D03.2 - Pluralistic valuation of ecosystem services. 2026. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.19569842
- ISO 690
- Sebastián Villasante; Gillian B. Ainsworth; Antía Campos; Andrés Ospina‐Álvarez; Francesco Bosello; Simone Libralato; Serena Zunino; Diana Lorena Rico-Velez; Donata Melaku Canu; Jamie D. Wilson; Anna Katavouta. AtlantECO Deliverable - D03.2 - Pluralistic valuation of ecosystem services. 2026. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.19569842
Warning: Undefined array key "last_link_verified" in /home/clients/e27d81e12f04d2bfd747aa264540ac56/sites/_UDTR_APP/legal_library_reference.php on line 31
UDTR Global Rights of Nature Legal Library. AtlantECO Deliverable - D03.2 - Pluralistic valuation of ecosystem services. Documentary record: https://www.declarationuniverselledesdroitsdelarbre.org/global-rights-of-nature-radar/reference/r-3fd07f62cc7b3fec353b4e075297ea7a/ · Last HTTP verification: not performed
Research dossiers and documentary relations
Source roles
Bibliographic / original publication source · https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.19569842
An authority link alone does not verify a legal claim. Abstracts and full texts remain subject to their source terms.
Documentary status
Relevance pending
Library
This identity is not yet included in the Legal Library.