{"id":"r-e2f50acfaeb98fd478c3d1071f11d111","title":"The Ecocentric Illusion: How Section 20 of the NGT Act, 2010 and the Doctrine of Proportionality Structurally Preclude Rights of Nature in India","authors":["Munni Debnath Parial"],"year":2026,"type":"scholarship","language":"en","jurisdictions":["IN"],"identifiers":{"doi":["10.70798/ijomr/03010017"],"openalex":["W7204989386"],"openaire":["doi_________::dee9a8b168486929072658cc59abc27e"]},"permanent_url":"https://www.declarationuniverselledesdroitsdelarbre.org/global-rights-of-nature-radar/reference/r-e2f50acfaeb98fd478c3d1071f11d111/","source_urls":["https://doi.org/10.70798/ijomr/03010017","https://openalex.org/W7204989386"],"courts":[],"publishers":[],"legislative_bodies":[],"reported_dates":[],"named_natural_entities":[],"book_relations":{"parent_book_id":null,"chapter_ids":[]},"documentary_status":"LEGAL_LIBRARY_INCLUDED","first_indexed":"2026-11-09T19:04:47.542818+00:00","last_metadata_update":"2026-11-10T16:58:51.492610+00:00","last_verified":null,"rights":"Bibliographic facts only; third-party source terms apply. No abstract/full-text redistribution.","recorded_source_links":[],"validation_status":"DOCUMENTARY_VALIDATED","public_library_admissible":true,"public_library_url":"https://www.declarationuniverselledesdroitsdelarbre.org/global-rights-of-nature-legal-library/?ref=ref-e2f50acfaeb98fd478c3d107","uglc_assessment":{"effectiveness":{"basis":"PUBLIC_RESEARCH_LEAD_INCOMPLETE","reason_en":"The available material is insufficient to determine this axis.","reason_fr":"Les éléments disponibles ne permettent pas de déterminer cet axe.","sources":[],"status":"INDETERMINABLE","terms":[]},"legal_status":{"basis":"PUBLIC_RESEARCH_LEAD_INCOMPLETE","reason_en":"The available material is insufficient to determine this axis.","reason_fr":"Les éléments disponibles ne permettent pas de déterminer cet axe.","sources":[],"status":"INDETERMINABLE","terms":[]},"object":{"basis":"PUBLIC_RESEARCH_LEAD_INCOMPLETE","reason_en":"The available material is insufficient to determine this axis.","reason_fr":"Les éléments disponibles ne permettent pas de déterminer cet axe.","sources":[],"status":"INDETERMINABLE","terms":[]},"obligations":{"basis":"AUTOMATIC_EVIDENCE_SUFFICIENCY_ASSESSMENT","reason_en":"The evidence currently available does not establish this axis; no targeted documentary lead is established at this stage. This revisable state means neither an absence of rights nor an absence of a legal mechanism.","reason_fr":"Les éléments actuellement disponibles ne permettent pas d’établir cet axe ; aucune piste documentaire ciblée n’est établie à ce stade. Cet état est révisable et ne signifie ni absence de droits ni absence de mécanisme juridique.","sources":[],"status":"INDETERMINABLE","terms":[]},"remedies":{"basis":"AUTOMATIC_EVIDENCE_SUFFICIENCY_ASSESSMENT","reason_en":"The evidence currently available does not establish this axis; no targeted documentary lead is established at this stage. This revisable state means neither an absence of rights nor an absence of a legal mechanism.","reason_fr":"Les éléments actuellement disponibles ne permettent pas d’établir cet axe ; aucune piste documentaire ciblée n’est établie à ce stade. Cet état est révisable et ne signifie ni absence de droits ni absence de mécanisme juridique.","sources":[],"status":"INDETERMINABLE","terms":[]},"representation":{"basis":"PUBLIC_RESEARCH_LEAD_INCOMPLETE","reason_en":"The available material is insufficient to determine this axis.","reason_fr":"Les éléments disponibles ne permettent pas de déterminer cet axe.","sources":[],"status":"INDETERMINABLE","terms":[]},"standing":{"basis":"AUTOMATIC_EVIDENCE_SUFFICIENCY_ASSESSMENT","reason_en":"The evidence currently available does not establish this axis; no targeted documentary lead is established at this stage. This revisable state means neither an absence of rights nor an absence of a legal mechanism.","reason_fr":"Les éléments actuellement disponibles ne permettent pas d’établir cet axe ; aucune piste documentaire ciblée n’est établie à ce stade. Cet état est révisable et ne signifie ni absence de droits ni absence de mécanisme juridique.","sources":[],"status":"INDETERMINABLE","terms":[]},"substantive_rights":{"basis":"PUBLIC_RESEARCH_LEAD_INCOMPLETE","reason_en":"The available material is insufficient to determine this axis.","reason_fr":"Les éléments disponibles ne permettent pas de déterminer cet axe.","sources":[],"status":"INDETERMINABLE","terms":[]}},"qualified_axis_count":0,"uglc_method":"UGLC_EVIDENCE_RESOLUTION_3.0","record_version":"277ee8dacb161ea8","provenance_url":"/api/v1/records/r-e2f50acfaeb98fd478c3d1071f11d111/provenance?snapshot=udtr-discovery-v3-certified-20261112T195315Z","author_identifiers":[],"institution_identifiers":[],"citation_data":{"id":"https://www.declarationuniverselledesdroitsdelarbre.org/global-rights-of-nature-radar/reference/r-e2f50acfaeb98fd478c3d1071f11d111/","type":"article-journal","URL":"https://www.declarationuniverselledesdroitsdelarbre.org/global-rights-of-nature-radar/reference/r-e2f50acfaeb98fd478c3d1071f11d111/","title":"The Ecocentric Illusion: How Section 20 of the NGT Act, 2010 and the Doctrine of Proportionality Structurally Preclude Rights of Nature in India","author":[{"literal":"Munni Debnath Parial"}],"issued":{"date-parts":[[2026]]},"language":"en","DOI":"10.70798/ijomr/03010017"},"legal_lifecycle":[],"source_link_assessment":[{"url":"https://doi.org/10.70798/ijomr/03010017","exists_in_metadata":true,"syntactically_valid":true,"resolves":"NOT_CHECKED","http_verified_at":null,"source_role":"discovery","source_role_is_not_legal_validation":true,"full_text_accessible":"NOT_TESTED_METADATA_ONLY"},{"url":"https://openalex.org/W7204989386","exists_in_metadata":true,"syntactically_valid":true,"resolves":"NOT_CHECKED","http_verified_at":null,"source_role":"discovery","source_role_is_not_legal_validation":true,"full_text_accessible":"NOT_TESTED_METADATA_ONLY"}],"legal_authority_status":"NOT_CONFERRED_BY_DISCOVERY"}